Best Cookie Shop Fort Wayne Near Me

Insomnia Cookies Cookie Cottage Inc Blondie's Cookies Sassie Cakes Courtney's Bakery Aunt Millie's Bakery Outlet Ft. Wayne, IN AmyBakes Rise'n Roll Bakery Rise'N Roll Bakery Zinnia's Bakehouse Sweet Cream Bakery by Fort Wayne Cakes For Goodness Cakes Pembroke Bakery & Cafe Costco Bakery

1. Insomnia Cookies - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 123 reviews

840 Calhoun St, Fort Wayne, IN 46802

Address Website WhatsApp
Insomnia Cookies: what do users think?
Nate: Order was supposed to be delivered within an hour, and it was over 20 minutes late. Also, they didn't bring it to me as requested but dropped it off at the front desk. No one notified me about it, and I only found out after I called the restaurant to find out where it was. And the cookies were only ok. It's not worth the wait.Ordered again 11 months later. No issues with the delivery. Cookies were delicious, prices still a bit high, but luckily, I had a $10 promo credit to make it cheaper.
Racheal Branning: Eh. That’s how insomnia cookies taste. They aren’t terrible, but definitely not worth the $14 for 6 cookies. My tastebuds were disappointed.
Taura Veazey: Some of the cookies are great, I guess it depends on your flavor you would like. I just care for the ordering process they have when placing the order and paying for your cookies... Too close for comfort.
Ariel Derrick: Brooke's we're delicious and has ice cream to go along with and clean place and nice customer service
Mallory Clester: I visited yesterday and it took 5 minutes for an employee to come out from the back to acknowledge my existence. I ordered, he disappeared into the back for another 10 minutes, came back out and there was an issue with the register (not his fault or a big deal). There was no line when I came in, but the whole thing took 25 minutes. The worst part is that the cookies are rock hard and stale. I can’t stress this enough- not worth the money at this location. Just don’t go.
Justin Wade: One employee in the store who was in the back most of the time, presumably dealing with online orders.Line went from 5 people to 12 people and we only saw the employee once. He took one order and disappeared in back again with no acknowledgement. So we left. Probably won't be back.
Austin B: Very good fresh melt in your mouth cookies. Will be back.
Danielle E: Super disappointed. I had never been there before and was excited to try. The man at the counter was very rude and obviously did not want to be there. The cookies were just so so and way too pricey. Overall, definitely not my favorite place to go for cookies in the Fort. 👎🏻
Tiffany Arnold: We love getting the lil drippers with butter creme icing and then the classic cookies are good. Double chocolate chip and peanut butter chip cookies are wonderful! The staff is always amazing! Go get ya some yummy, fresh cookies!!
lex: I ordered DoorDash from here for the first time and I go out to check and this is what I see: My cookie box upside down with a cookie on the ground, and I’m missing 3 cookies from my order.I contacted DoorDash and received a partial refund but I’ll never order from here again. Even though I used DoorDash, I think an employee of Insomnia Cookies delivered these because I wasn’t assigned a ‘Dasher’ or had any contact info for them. Which, I use DoorDash pretty regularly and know how they operate. I called Insomnia Cookies to talk about this issue and was sent straight to a full voicemail box. This was a terrible experience. Don’t ever order from here.
Bailey F.: I'm not sure what happened with the staff because when I first came to this location, they were great. Very friendly. But the last two times, the staff seemed like they barely wanted to help and barely spoke to me even though I was being friendly. The cookies are incredible but the customer service needs some work.
Jessica Blasius: The cookies are incredible. The choices for different cookies and what you can add to them is really nice. Wish they took cash and were a little more affordable though.
Carrie Miller: Great deserts and friendly staff.
Michael Tome: Cookies looked good just not very flavored and hard.
Alyssa Alanis: I ordered tonight and they forgot a cookie. I wasn't upset, but was hoping for a refund for the one cookie. The customer service went above and beyond. They brought us a whole new set of cookies and a refund without me knowing. I am so blown away by how amazingly they responded! They have my business forever simply because of this act of kindness! I believe her name was Berna, but you are the best!!
Matthew Underwood: Great for a quick desert after dinner or seeing a show
Lily Ritchie: Very expensive and berna burnt my cookies.
Karissa Marley: Best place around town to get cookies! Always soft, fresh, and warm!
Sara Conley: Delicious cookies and outstanding customer service 😋
karen whittaker: snikerdoodles are delicious..
Garret Kamine: Wife and I treated ourselves to cookies with DoorDash. Purchased a dozen and they arrived quickly, no issues with the delivery. The cookies however were disappointing, especially for the premium price. All except the chocolate chunks were rock hard and crunchy. The chocolate chunks were better but still not what we expect from Insomnia. Probably won't buy anymore. Cookie cottage is less expensive and higher quality.

2. Cookie Cottage Inc - Fort Wayne

Verified

Verified

· 707 reviews

620 W Washington Center Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp
Cookie Cottage Inc: what do users think?
Derrick B: The Cookes are great 🤩
Maralee Whitesell: Absolutely delicious
Charles Lehman: Fantastic cookies!
Donna Williams: Got these as a gift and they were awesome! So fresh and yummy!
Liz Moran: Best white macadamia nut cookies!
Travis Farney: Best sugar cookies I've ever had in my life. 10/10, I always make a point to stop by when I'm in town, living 2 hours away. But nothing else compares IMO! Keep killing it
Starr Sapp: Best cookie place in fort wayne.
Andrew Clodfelter: I recently had the pleasure of visiting Cookie Cottage, and I have to say, I'm absolutely in love! From the moment I walked in, the delicious scent of freshly baked cookies hit me like a warm, comforting hug.And let me tell you, these cookies are out of this world! They're so delicious, I almost started doing cartwheels right then and there in the store. I mean, who needs a workout when you've got Cookie Cottage cookies to keep you energized and happy all day long?But it's not just the cookies themselves that are amazing - it's the whole experience of being in the store. The staff are so friendly and welcoming, it's like they're old friends you've known your whole life. And the colorful, whimsical decor just adds to the fun and happy vibe of the place.Honestly, if you're ever feeling down, just head on over to Cookie Cottage and you'll leave feeling like a million bucks. It's the ultimate pick-me-up destination, and I can't recommend it highly enough!
Andy: Amazing cookies, can't beat these anywhere locally.
Robert Trexler: Had a request from Marion, IN that was craving their cookies!
ross brewer: First time customer and let me tell you I'll be going back alot. I can't believe I waited so long to try.
Ron Reichhart: No place makes cookies like the famous Cookie Cottage. Valentines day was busy but the staff was prepared and organized making the long line move along. There are no bad cookies here
J B: I have been to their previous location and this location. A wide variety of cookies. They also have cards that you can buy. My top 3 cookies are: Chocolate Chip, Macadamia White Chocolate, and Oatmeal Scotchie. Not a fan of the Iced Sugar or Snickerdoodle.
L W: A true Fort Wayne treasure! You won't find better cookies anywhere around. Do yourself a favor and just order twice as many that you walked in to get - you won't regret it!
Jen Sneiderwine: All the ladies are pleasant and ready to answer your question. You are in and out in a flash. You can never have just one of the best tasting cookies ever!
Ranada Clark: Best cookies, EVER!
Tim Zickmund: They make it look easy being the best!
Tana Vandeputte: Love, love, love!!!!
Elizabeth Perez: always wonderful and well stocked. we stop I several times a year and are beyond pleased. one of my favorite local cookie places!
Kevin Hauff: Best cookies in the Fort.
Glen Stonestreet: Best Cookies

3. Blondie's Cookies - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 86 reviews

4201 Coldwater Rd Ste 334, Fort Wayne, IN 46805

Address Website WhatsApp
Blondie's Cookies: what do users think?
Brittany Mitchell: Ordered Grubhub for dessert for the fam. Wanted to try something new so tried Blondie’s. Buy 6 get 1 free. $22. However we only got 5 cookies out of the 7 we ordered, and they tasted like they were baked about a week ago. The snickerdoodle was edible but the white chocolate macadamia literally tasted rotten. The chocolate chip is mediocre at best. I imagine if they were fresher they’d taste at least a little bit better but even then the cookies just didn’t look good in general. The chocolate chip looked like a frozen pillsbury cookie, with 3 chocolate chips in total. Just overall really disappointing.
Amarra Paulk: Pricey but they're the best you'll ever eat
Brittany Myers: Still trying to figure out why we paid $15 for one small brownie and a rock hard cookie.
Tiffany Henderson: These cookies are amazing!My only issue it that I can not find the nutritional information anywhere.I buy less cookies then I want because I am not sure exactly what I I am getting so I can't work them into my diet for treat times.
linda Anderson: The cookies at Blondies weren't impressive to us, for the price we paid.
Chris Hall: Love it
Courtney kemp: Some friends came to town with their 3 kids and I have a 2 year old myself. We had to go to the mall. We had lunch there and I decided to get the kids all cookies. I walked up to the blondie employee and asked how much a dozen was. She said for a dozen it starts at $13 something. I thought to myself that's not a bad price. I got 6 sugar cookies with plain iceing. 4 chocolate chip, 2 penut butter blossoms (a peanut butter cookie with a Hershey kiss on top), 2 m&m cookies. Nothing special right. It was THIRTY DOLLARS! At no point did the employee let me know that any of the cookies I picked were extra. She shoved them in a bag and wrapped the sugar cookies with icing to where there was 2 cookies in one piece of wax paper so they stuck together. And the chocolate completely fell off the blossoms. It was just a bag of messy by the time I got home. I should have walked away after she told me $30. We will never go here again
randi Castillo: I got my son a cookie cake for his 16th bday .and it's raw cookie dough inside not cook all the way just nasty and for 30$ come on ....
Catina Small: The cookies looked delicious but after I picked out the one I wanted and was told it would be $10.99 for one cookie I declined. No cookie is worth that much. I will stick with my home town bakery who makes delicious cookies that are affordable and taste great. Still in shock that anyone would pay that for one cookie. Guess that’s why they don’t display their prices on their treats😳
Kimberly Hathaway: I could absolutely eat there cookies every day for the rest of my life if that was an option! The frosted sugar cookie is just chefs kiss, it's almost too good.
Mike Kendall: Good cookies at fair price
Tom Kracium: 3 people working. 2 standing around on their phones while the 1 person worked. If i dodnt want cookies for a friends birthday party I would have left
Stephanie Eibling: Best place to go when ur wanting something sweet. Love their designs on the cookies
lorri klingenberger: Not good
T “SweetT&Family” Dom: Not the same cookie are hard and stale.
Taylor JI: Pricey and stale . 5$ for two old cookies? Not sure how they're in business
kevin B: Loved the giant chocolate chip cookie cake
Graham Stiver: Delicious cookies as always
Becky Taylor: The cookies are good, but very high priced.
Jack W. Sawmiller: Bad thing is....to many good choices!
sandra ortiz: Absolutely love the chocolate chip and frosted sugar cookies. Also tried the german chocolate frosted brownie today and it was awesome. I definitely stop here every time I visit the mall.

4. Sassie Cakes - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 67 reviews

1014 Broadway St, Fort Wayne, IN 46802

Address Website WhatsApp
Sassie Cakes: what do users think?
Andrea Lichtsinn: We ordered a cake for our Baby's first birthday. Every expectation we had was exceeded. Thank you so much for your hard work. It was beautiful and delicious.
Dehily Dehily: Always gorgeous cakes. I have used them for my daughter's birthday cakes. I always just tell them the theme and my budget and let then roll with it. I have never been disappointed! The cakes are beautiful and tasty.
Kristi Giant: I stopped for 4 cupcakes as a treat and my husband and I ate all if them that night! They were A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!
Kaye Oberg: Last minute ordered a custom cookies and cream jumbo cupcake! They had it ready the next day fresh and ready to go just in time for my daughters party!
Allison Hanford: Was looking through my wedding photos and I still LOVE my cake from 7 years ago! Great bakery and the flavor was amazing :)
Jennifer Deacon: So good! My snickerdoodle cupcake was most delicious. The service has been always been friendly with each visit! Thank you!
angela Flores: My favorite treat in Ft Wayne is an oatmeal raisin sandwich cookie from Sassie Cakes. We have been fans since the tiny Waynedale store, where I first fell in love with the cupcakes. I am a big fan of wedding white and the PB&J, and my husband loves the Snickerdoodle. The downtown shop is a fun stop on the way home, and the kids behind the counter are top notch. I'd give 10 stars if I could!!
Stealthninja135: The kid up front real gentlemen to my elderly mother
Carla Castro: Stopped by, wanting something to satisfy our sweet tooth! Great selection of cupcakes and gourmet desserts, affordable pricing, and wonderful customer service! The owner and staff were friendly and as sweet as their treats! Would definitely recommend and would go again and again!
Corey Rader: Great cakes and deserts in a historic building in the heart of downtown. Glad you all are here!
Carrie Korican: Great business. Super professional and talented.
Ashley Jylland-Hade: Krysta + team make the most beautiful and delicious cakes in town! Very professional and prompt.
amber Reynolds: I have had the pleasure of enjoying sassy cakes cupcakes since she was here in Waynedale! Never once have I had a bad experience the cupcakes are always delish and the staff is always so warming and sweet! I will always tell everyone to go to sassy cakes for their baking needs she’s the absolute best!
Cassie Lettenberger: Great service! Great cakes, cupcakes and those macaroons are amazing! I’ve had cakes done for my daughters birthday 3 years in a row! Also, cupcakes for her baby shower on St. Patrick’s Day! Always amazing! Always accommodating! I will always recommend Sassie Cakes to everyone and anyone in need fabulous desserts!
Damon Pittenger: We discovered this incredible place when my wife and I were planning our wedding. Everything about this bakery is amazing. The folks that run it are some of the sweetest(pun intended) people, and everything they create is absolute perfection. The only warning I will give is that if you get anything from them, you will not be able to stay away. You'll always make your way back for some cupcakes, and you won't be able to stop yourself. Thank you all for everything you do!!!
Amy Hannon: Amazing cakes/treats! Have ordered many times for special occasions and have never been disappointed on the taste or design of cakes. Krysta has the best vision for decorating on the most special of occasions. Amazing staff! Always professional, kind, very easy to work with both on a business and personal level. Always my #1 recommendation and have never had a family member or client disappointed either!
Kirsten Braun: Some of the best cake I have had!!! been to many weddings / events and Sassie made the cakes !!! never disappoints !!!! love supporting local
Kelsey Korthal: my husband and i used sassie cakes for our wedding cake and we could not have been happier! our cake and cupcakes were delicious and turned out just how we imagined. from the original consult to being able to take home cupcakes for taste testing to the delivery and set up on our wedding day everything was perfect. i HIGHLY recommend sassie cakes to anyone who is in the market for a cake for any occasion!!
Kyle Thele: Sassie Cakes has been a part of just about every major event for our family over the last few years. The cakes and baked goods speak for themselves. But it really is so nice having a local sweets shop like this in town. Great people
Arianna Papadakis: For my wedding we had a variety of cupcake flavors, a cake, and macaroons! The colors were perfect, every flavor was delicious and the price was great! The owner is lovely to work with and she's genuinely so excited to help make your day!
maricela dickson: I ordered from Sassie cakes a while ago for our foster sons BirthdaysWe ordered a Captain America cake and A Hulk smash cake. The two Cakes exceeded my expectations and turned out just how I imagined them! There was speedy response time and great communication not only from owner but from her staff. Definitely will order from them again in the future. Plus the cake was delicious.

5. Courtney's Bakery - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 343 reviews

7773 Coldwater Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp
Courtney's Bakery: what do users think?
Donna Garcia: I had them make cupcakes for my sons birthday snack for his preschool and we wanted Miles morales themed (Spider-Man) ones. I am very please with the outcome!
Chanda Newsome: Courtney's Bakery did a fabulous job on my Dad's 70th German Chocolate Birthday cake. My request for a Florida theme was perfect with cute Palm Trees and a surprise with Seashells. Not to mention the cake was so delicious!! Highly recommend! Fabulous Service!!!
Alina Vo: My boyfriend got me my DREAM cake for my 25th birthday! They absolutely nailed the cake flavors & the design! Thank you guys so so much! ❤️
Anita cuautle: My boyfriend wanted to surprise me with a cake two weeks before my birthday. They told him they couldn't do the cake he wanted, but still would do a cake for him. They didn't even bother to help him in a direction for my cake. Needless to say, when we got the cake it looked like a Kroger cake. He spent too much money for a cake that could of came from Kroger and just in their box. Everyone from my party was upset with how the cake looked, and questioned where did it really come from! Worst cake from here!!
Jason Herzfeld: Hands down the best bakery in town, Courtney's bakery will forever be our cake place
Patti Niday: I will return ....the cake I ordered for my Daughter in law was fantastic... I didnt get a photo... but I chose Balloons for the icing decorations it looked wonderful.... the Cake was a Round Double layer with the Buttercream in between the layers which by the way they did not skimp on... perfect amount I might say...the actual cake flavor was Raspberry which is her favorite and mine to. The cake was very moist as well not dry at all and it was reasonably priced. I used to order my cakes from Don Halls it takes a cake.....since they are no longer in business I have been searching to find a Rasberry flavored cake with Buttercream frosting......I FOUND IT!! Thank you to Courtney's Bakery for the wonderful cake and great service.....I also purchased some iced sugar cookies for my Grandgirl and they were excellent. Thanks again...5 star rating in my book....all the way around.
Karen Barrett: They're cupcakes are awesome! I've had their cake once and it was very very good....both I would get again and again. Sorry, I'm just not a fan of their cookies, to me.... they have that commercial texture and flavor, or moreover- lack of deliciousness homemade flavor.
Ruthy Waltz: My grand son works there he seems to love his job and for that I'm thankful you don't see that every day there doing something great in there he hasn't complained yet lol
Bob Mason: Excellent cookies and cupcakes
KBF: Rude,Would not say their name when they answered the phone.They seemed annoyed with me like I was interrupting them.
Shivalli Rai: Got my baby shower cake!Amazing design and flavor
Drew Conrady: Very happy with the cake they made came out better then I could ask for!
Thomas Gaskill: Ordered a yellow cake with Bavarian cream center and chocolate frosting. Absolutely the best cake!
Kaitlin Hubbard: My 3 year old adored her cake for her birthday! Tasted amazing and was very well done! One of the highlights of her party today. Huge plus being able to pick out the cake online and do all the ordering that way! Only thing I wish was different is when ordering online to be able to put what her name was instead of just happy birthday, but if it was a big deal I would have just called, but just an idea 😁 thank you so much!
Rakhel Dahms: Courtney’s Bakery has been a place to order cakes and buy cupcakes. Their cakes are tasty and moist. Last time I had to order a birthday cake one day before the birthday and they accepted my order. It’s easy to order from them because I can just do it online on their website. The cake turned out pretty and tasted really good!
Kaylina Porter: My boyfriend got me cupcakes from here today. Honestly probably the best cupcake I have ever had in my life. Will definitely be a return customer.
Eric Sanderson: Went here for the first time three weeks ago and the cupcakes where awesome. The staff was one of the best staffs I have ever been around.
Tanya Swinehart: My sister got my daughter a raspberry cake with the raspberry filling and cream cheese frosting. The cake was so delicious! It was the best cake I’d ever eaten! Thank You Courtney’s Bakery!
Terry Isley: Snobby, unfriendly on 2 visits. Bakery items were good.
Jeremy Spray: Really nice staff. Really top notch baked goods. The bakery doesn't hit the pocket to hard. 👍👍👍👍👍😁😁😁😁😁.
Jennifer Harris: Ordered my husbands 60th birthday cake from Courtney's. Did not disappoint! Got the almond cake with raspberry filling and buttercream frosting. It was done on time, decorated as requested. Most importantly it was delicious. If a cake looks pretty but is dry and flavorless it doesn't really matter does it? Well this hit all the marks. It was beautiful, fresh, moist and full of flavor. I would definately order from here again.

6. Aunt Millie's Bakery Outlet Ft. Wayne, IN - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 156 reviews

4001 Kraft Pkwy, Fort Wayne, IN 46818

Address Website WhatsApp

7. AmyBakes - Leo-Cedarville

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 28 reviews

14720 Bobcat Ct, Leo, IN 46765

Address Website WhatsApp

8. Rise'n Roll Bakery - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 986 reviews

5129 Illinois Rd #101, Fort Wayne, IN 46804

Address Website WhatsApp

9. Rise'N Roll Bakery - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 344 reviews

511 E Dupont Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp

10. Zinnia's Bakehouse - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 109 reviews

236 E Wayne St, Fort Wayne, IN 46802

Address Website WhatsApp

11. Sweet Cream Bakery by Fort Wayne Cakes - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 69 reviews

2339 Crescent Ave, Fort Wayne, IN 46805

Address Website WhatsApp

12. For Goodness Cakes - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 73 reviews

5925 N Clinton St, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp

13. Pembroke Bakery & Cafe - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 140 reviews

300 E Main St # 102, Fort Wayne, IN 46802

Address Website WhatsApp

14. Costco Bakery - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 2 reviews

1001 Paramount Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46808

Address Website WhatsApp

add a comment of Cookie shop Fort Wayne

Comment sent successfully! We will review it in the next few hours.