Best Insurance Agency Fort Wayne Near Me

Colligan & Company - Insurance Agency The Wise Insurance Agency Huff & Campbell Insurance Agency Inc Berner & Company Insurance Mathews Insurance Agency, Inc. Schultheis Agency Insurance Ovation Insurance Amstutz Insurance Tom Steckler Agency Inc Cornerstone Insurance Auto Express Insurance Family Insurance Services Granville Insurance Affordable Insurance Agency INC

1. Colligan & Company - Insurance Agency - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 124 reviews

9602 Coldwater Rd Suite 106, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp
Colligan & Company - Insurance Agency: what do users think?
Carolyn Swanson: Top notch! Always at an arms length when you need something done right away! Thank you Kyle for always being there when we need you!
Génesis Cruz: Best atención
David Jenks: Great experience working with Dustin at Colligan Insurance. Very knowledgable and easy to work with plus now I never have to worry about checking each year if I have the best rates because he does it for me automatically.
vanessa pendergraft: This is my first time buying insurance on my own, and Dustin was patient while thoroughly explaining my new insurance to me and answering all my questions. I hope to maintain a relationship with Colligan and Company as I believe they have found me the best deal for my car insurance needs. I heard of them from a friend referral who was satisfied with the services that Colligan provided to them. They respond to my emails quickly, even when they are not in the office!
Deb Radford: I've never had an issue or question that they didn't take care of immediately. Best insurance company ever.
Jason Stockman: Pain free and perfect price point. Mr. Shirey was friendly and professional through the entire process while providing fast service. His focus on the needs and details of a home and auto insurance was evident as to provide the best deal with the best coverage.
Jordan Blevins: Ask for Dustin he was super helpful and didn’t make me feel like I was bothering him at all! Patient and very eager to help!
Laura Cronkhite: Excellent in every way!
Colleen Majszak: Dustin is always incredibly responsive and helpful. When the insurance company we went with was not responding to our calls, Dustin emailed the adjuster personally to find out what was going on and did a wonderful job of keeping us updated. Thank you so much, Dustin!
Brandi Gilstrap: Dustin Shirey was very helpful and got me just what I needed. 10/10 would recommend
Alisha Lyons: Super easy to get insurance for your home. They have the best pay options out of all that I called.
Ian H: Dustin is terrific.. awesome experience start to finish. I appreciate his professionalism and recommend him to my friends and associates.
Annette: Dustin was recommended by family when I finally decided to look for better rates after 25+ years with another company. He replied immediately, answered my questions, and found me better coverage with my homeowners policy.
Greg Buckel: Dustin was courteous, informed, and obviously up-to-date on the process for switching our insurance policies over to Westfield.
Mallory Walker: Dustin worked after hours to make sure that I was 100% insured and good to drive my first car the second I got my license. I really couldn’t recommend any other insurance company and insurance broker. Really made the experience stress free, effective, and quick! Thank you Dustin!
Jeremy Hyde: We invite you to "Get A Quote" and see that we offer more than that!
Alice Martin: Neil has been extremely helpful and has gone above and beyond to ensure I was aware of the products, process and great service!
Derrick Mckibben: Neil Stumpf is a great insurance agent. He knew just what I needed and got me a great rate that saved me money. He fully covered my vehicle for less money than I was paying with a national competitor with only half the coverage. He was very knowledgeable and was easy to reach when I had questions. I would recommend him to anyone!
Jacqueline Shepherd: I have worked with Dustin at Colligan & Company for several years. The company has been with me through some accidents as I was younger. In addition, they helped me through an issue from an uninsured motorist, and I recently had the pleasure of working with them for preparing insurance for my first home.Dustin has always been quick to respond when I have reached out, and he has been able to answer questions on my policy when needed.I couldn't be happier with the service I have received from Dustin. I highly recommend him and Colligan & Company!
Brad Huston: Dustin was professional and courteous. He helped us find a great policy to fit our needs and was always quick to respond. Would recommend working with him!
Deborah O'Kelly: Dustin was friendly and helpful. When you call the office you actually talk to a person. Dustin was able to increase our insurance coverage while lowering premium costs. Amazing.

2. The Wise Insurance Agency - Fort Wayne

Verified

Verified

· 134 reviews

7410 Bluffton Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46809

Address Website WhatsApp
The Wise Insurance Agency: what do users think?
Abby Harner: Jeana Ingram at Wise Insurance Agency is extremely helpful and is always going above and beyond to make your experience as good as it can be, even in difficult situations.Abby
Patricia L. Shelton: Wise Insurance has always been professional and friendly when dealing with me, and patient when I've been confused or needed help with my policy. I would recommend them to anyone looking for insurance coverage.
Matt Shonkwiler: Initially rated this 5 stars, but have had turnover in agent multiple times in my first year. On my 3rd agent in 1 year. Neither time was I made aware of the change until after it happened and I reached out the agency. Found errors in my prior home policy that would have likely caused significant trouble with coverage if a claim would have been submitted.
Linda Zehr: Nice staff. Quick turnaround. Very helpful.
wanda stacy: Absolute pleasure to work with!
Joel Shrock: I have used them for years. No matter which agent is working with me, I've always saved money and had better coverage at the same time. As a realtor, I've referred them to multiple clients which have reciprocated thanks for referring them for their insurance needs.
woodrow ormiston: Always very professional, friendly and helpful in every aspect!
Josie Dellinger: Shannon Pardus (with Johanna’s help) just gave us excellent service with our insurance. We were trying to insure our son, who is in the military, and being out-of-state it looked like it was going to turn into a giant headache. Shannon and Johanna talked to the car dealership for us and got it straightened out. We are so grateful for their help! Thank you!
Fred Spencer: I have been very satisfied with these folks managing my home and auto insurance needs.
Matt Minear: They are always attentive and answer the phone quickly.
Michael Hoban: Great place to do business for your insurance needs!
Frederick Rose: I'm a former insurance agent and agency owner out of California, it's very competitive there in California. Cynthia Jones at Wise was the only agent, out of 3 other broker agencies I called that not only got the quotes done before the others did, but she called me when she was done, I never received any calls from the other agencies, I had to bug them?! One of the agencies acted like they didn't even care if they got my business, this was personal and business insurance package, a decent size insurance deal. Another agency misquoted the business package by a lot, and was way under price, purposely? I don't know, but Cindy was quoting the same insurance company as they were! The last agency never even returned my initial phone call to get a quote! Another one of those how do they stay in business places.I'm dumbfounded as to how those other agents can survive financially! If I had run my agency like those other agencies here, I would have been out of business fast and doing something else for a living.So yes, I recommend the Wise agency and Cynthia Jones as an agent over the other major agencies in Fort Wayne.
Austin Vega: Julie was an amazing help! We had a huge problem with our insurance 2 days before closing and Julie helped us find a policy for us and get it finalized for closing! Excellent service
Jonathan Knight: Always a swift response time, very professional, and always finding me the best rates
Ben Hendricks: Jeana Ingram has always been a great representative to work with. She is prompt and organized in getting us our renewal information on time as well as shopping for the best rates for our Auto and Homeowners insurance. When we need changes made, she does a fantastic job in getting the necessary information back to us in a timely manner!
Mike Humphrey: Very professional, highly recommended.
OnTimeEveryTime: Fantastic agency and even better agents. Honest, dependable, and courteous service. They shop rates before asking when renewing policies and quick to help. I'd say I'm a tough critic, but this group exceeds expectations.
Lon Jones: Responsive to inquiries. Local and independent so able to shop multiple companies.
Erica Shonkwiler: Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,ValueHarrison was amazing to work with! After 12 years with another company that didn't quite give us what we needed, we were overwhelmed by how helpful, communicative, and resourceful Harrison was. He saved us enough money in a year to add another vacation!
Rick Martin del Campo: These people are great! They did my renter’s insurance and will be doing my homeowners soon! Arianna is very personable and has hand-held me through the process every time. Highly recommend
Mike Flores: Positive:Professionalism,Quality,ResponsivenessArianna Sanchez is so prompt, knowledgeable, and a true professional.

3. Huff & Campbell Insurance Agency Inc - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 7 reviews

4233 E State Blvd #2, Fort Wayne, IN 46815

Address Website WhatsApp
Huff & Campbell Insurance Agency Inc: what do users think?
Peter Callahan: Great place for insurance. Nice, helpful staff. Been a customer for 20 years.
Joseph Schaper: They always go above and beyond for my company
Cyan Rose: Rude!
Andrew Geier: Great Place to buy insurance, Kelly is the best!
MinMin World: Nice employee

4. EPCO Insurance Agency - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 9 reviews

6010 E State Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN 46815

Address Website WhatsApp
EPCO Insurance Agency: what do users think?
Noel Ochoa: I have been working with them for years, they are great!
Sheila Sells: Love having Troy do our taxes!
Vickie Gordon: Helpful in every way! Friendly!
Mike Lepper: Excellent service and great people to work with for your needs. Would recommend
Mary Hildenbrand: Have been getting my taxes done here for years. ThanksTim.
Adventurous Scooters: Over the years some of the faces have changed, but the work ethics are still the best in my book.I started home owners insurance with them in the 70's and left for a while to price shop. I eventually went back to EPCO and plan on staying now.Bob has done my Taxes since 1975 and will continue until he retires.You won't find a better place to do business. Judy is very friendly and professional at the front counter. I wish I could give a 10 Star for the rating.John

5. Berner & Company Insurance - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 13 reviews

10538 Coldwater Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46845

Address Website WhatsApp
Berner & Company Insurance: what do users think?
Catherine Compton: Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Caballo Loco: Longevity and honest service.
Joel Webb: I've used Berner for my Auto and Home insurance for 10+ years. I've even re-quoted a dozen of other companies for comparable rates and service a few years ago. Rates are at or below anyone else, and their customer service makes them jump way to the top. You really can't find any better. They make everything so easy!
kevin sayers: I switched to Berner after getting many quotes from many insurance companies and they were by far and away the most competitive and they are local as well. The process to start up was quick and painless and I am very happy with them.
steven showers: Tim and his team have served us well for nearly a decade. At one point, when our renewal price jumped considerably, I did not have to call them... they called me and helped us find better coverage.
Jeffrey Bowman: When I moved back to Fort Wayne in the late 80's, Tim Berner was one of the first people I met and became friends with. He has handled all of our insurance needs for over the last 30 years, vehicle, motorcycle, various houses we owned in Fort Wayne and Greenwood, life and health. I throw away any, junk, mail I get from other agents, don't even open it.
J Watson: For your all of your insurance needs,call Tim Berner !I have been with this company for 10 years. All of my personal, commercial/ business insurance policies are in their hands. I appreciate Tim's patience and candy bowl ;)
Lynn Berry: Excellent service and very responsive to any claims. I highly recommend Berner & Company.
Ann Marqueling: Berner and Company have been providing our family with all our insurance needs for over 30 years. Tim and his team are knowledgeable, friendly and handle all our needs efficiently.
Zachary Grubbs: I’ve had Berner & Company for a long time, and they’ve been awesome. I’ve had a couple of car accidents and they’ve been great through all the paperwork. Rates are great too!
Nancy Ann: Outstanding customer service! Berner & Co. is the ONLY insurance we've used for over 26 years.
Kathryne Monteith: I've been with this company for years. I've never had an issue and all claims have been dealt with quickly. Now my kids are joining Berner.

6. Mathews Insurance Agency, Inc. - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 22 reviews

4011 W Jefferson Blvd Suite 210, Fort Wayne, IN 46804

Address Website WhatsApp
Mathews Insurance Agency, Inc.: what do users think?
Jeffrey D Fuller: Good people running the place. They've done a good job keeping my insurance rates as low as possible.And when I hit a deer last fall, they handled it quickly, fairly, and I was able to get a rental and head to work. They brought the paperwork and checks directly to me at my place of employment.
Jeff Jenkins: The agents there r always helpful & get u the best deals...
David Grear: This is a good place to get house and car insurance . that will help you ?
al isham: Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Valuevery helpful
Jeffery “Jeppy” Jenkins: Every helpful & always looking for the best deal for u...
sharron shields: Thanks for all the help!
laurie bryce: Saved me enough on my home and cars that I was able to get a life insurance policy as well. Very happy!
jr vargas: very helpful
dottie tangeman: good service
richard henderson: friendly service and good pricing
Stephanie Clamme: I have had my insurance with Mathews for 5 years. I have always had great customer service.
Steven Cirino: Terrible company, agent is almost always never available, must leave multiple voicemails just to get a call back days later. Most recently, I was told the day of scheduled repairs, that I don't have rental coverage, when my previous vehicle that was totaled, got me a rental for two weeks. I did nothing to request my policy to be different so why is this happening? I have no idea because once again, no one is answering the phone. Do yourself a favor, and stay far away from this company.
Ade Zarate: Esta bien
Jordan James: I have been trying to get a refund from my insurance company and my agent told me that she would call them to get my refund then call me back with an update and she never has. Every time I call up there she is either not there or “busy” . Still waiting for my refund

7. Schultheis Agency Insurance - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 12 reviews

1910 St Joe Center Rd STE 11, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp
Schultheis Agency Insurance: what do users think?
Greg Cook: Called and spoke with Adam. When I told him that I was looking for insurance and that I shop every time it is time for renewal, he told me "I am not your guy". Told me he only deals with people who we are loyal and renew. Seems ridiculous to not want business from someone. If you are offering a good service at a good rate, people will renew. But to require a commitment to renew before even giving a quote is crazy. Business must be great to turn away customers. Told him I will take my business elsewhere.
Wayne Kaley: Adam is a great agent! He is personable, he is always on top of things, and will even take time-out of his schedule to meet in the even and weekends.
jon mermann: I am fortunate to be able to call the Beauchot family personal friends, but any clients of Schultheis Agency are doubly lucky if they can call any member of this family their insurance agent. In August I was passing through Fort Wayne after a family funeral when a truck tire exploded and caused considerable damage to my vehicle. Not only did Adam chauffeur my passenger, his dog, and me to a hotel, but Susan filed the initial claim for me while I scrambled to make plans to get home...and they aren't even my agents; but they will be when my policy renews. Having been an insurance agent myself I am very impressed (and grateful!) by how well organized the Schultheis office and operations are, and how rapidly they respond when help is needed. I never thought I'd need to file a claim, and this family took very good care of me when it wasn't even their responsibility to.
robbie reed: Positive:QualityAdam is an amazing agent an helpful straight to the point in making sure you get what you need an being affordable!!
Bill Brown: Forget the advertising campaign you see all the time Susan's the best locally owned and operated she'll get it done when other people can't
Jeanie Hess: Customers needs and reassurance are number one!
TracyAnn Renfro: Been with this company for many years. The staff is helpful and kind. Highly recommend!!
Sheri McBride: Personal service in a family environment. Saved money too!!!

8. Godschalk & Associates Insurance - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 4 reviews

405 Lower Huntington Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46819

Address Website WhatsApp
Godschalk & Associates Insurance: what do users think?
F Johns: Love these people. They really look out for you!
Steve Ashcraft: This agency is top notch. Excellent staff, very knowledgeable and friendly. Awesome customer service.
Brad Black: Great agency with amazing agents and wonderful service.

9. Ovation Insurance - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 169 reviews

6058 E State Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN 46815

Address Website WhatsApp
Ovation Insurance: what do users think?
Seller Q: This insurance agency is great! They are very prompt, organized, and sell very good insurance products at a fair price. I would highly recommend that you reach out to them to service all of your insurance needs.
Candace Hoffacker: Professional, knowledgeable, friendly, and patient! Appreciate how Sharon took the time to let me review the policies, ask questions, and not pressure with alot of phone calls! An excellent customer service experience.
eva chupp: I worked with Joel Dunham and he was super efficient and set me up with exactly what I needed, and answered all my questions quickly!
Emily Rauschenbach: Working with Ovation has always been an amazing experience. They really do a great job in making sure there are no headaches in finding the best coverage options for all areas of my life, answering any and all questions, and ensuring that I never have to think about finding what is right for my family.
Sharon Kuhn: Joel, Lora and Sharon have always been outstanding, caring and helpful. Ovation is quick to resolve issues when I've made an error on payment or had a claim. I highly recommend the company and their people!
Randy Humerickhouse: Professional service and treated like family.
Stacey Bumgarner: Sharon was great to work with. She was friendly with good info and quick with the info needed.
Kimberly Clark: I moved my Homeowners and Auto Insurance to Ovation in 2020 and was so happy with the service that I just moved the Commercial Insurance to Ovation. Very easy to work with.
Kaitlin Withers: I have been being taken care of recently by Amanda Stoller at Ovation, and what a game changer. Amanda has been incredibly helpful with both my home and auto insurance. She’s been able to get me a lower deductible at a better rate all around without losing any coverage, an all around win if you ask me. Amanda had also been so flexible with me and my schedule and communication preferences. Thanks to her, it has been a wonderful, stress-free experience, especially compared to the other agencies I have spoke to previously in my recent insurance shopping. 10/10 recommend Ovation - Amanda especially!
Adam Nuest: This was my first time working with ovation Insurance. Joel did a great job going over my options! Super simple and easy. Thank you for your hard work Joel!
Red Roof Inn: Working with Joel has been great. He found me better rates with more coverage than other insurance company. He has been very responsive and I look forward to working with him for my insurance needs for all our businesses.
Dennise Quintana: I have been with Oviation insurance for about two years now with Sharon and Lora. I can't recommend them enough, they go above and beyond, everything is so easy , highly recommend.
tonya donahue: I’ve worked with Ovation Insurance for years, and they have always been excellent. I’ve worked with Joel, Amanda, and Lora, and each of them have been patient and helpful, answering all of my questions. They are efficient and get you everything you need in a stress-free, timely fashion. I would not choose to use any other insurance agency.
Alaina Philbee: Sharon is always very helpful. She makes finding the best deal easy. Thank you!
Deb Jagger: I am very pleased with the first interaction with Ovation Insurance. I requested quotes for home and vehicle insurance, and received information within three hours. The agent was very informative and courteous. I recommend this company to anyone who is looking for insurance.
K Cooper: Great service super friendly!!! Mrs. Cooper is very knowledgeable and friendly....she really knows her stuff!!!!!
Jake Huffman: They make finding the right insurance so easy and convenient. They find the best deals and always make sure I understand the policies and how they best meet my needs.Lora and Amanda have the greatest customer service. Even if I'm horribly slow to respond back :)Not only have they been great to work with, but they save me so much money too.
Lisa Bresley: I love Ovation Insurance! So far I have worked with Joel Dunham and Lora Lyons and they are incredibly professional and knowledgeable. When we had an emergency, Joel was available right away to help. Just excellent service all around and we couldn't ask for a better insurance company!
Timothy Metzger: Joel Dunham with Ovation Insurance has been great. He has been more than happy to explain different policies to help us understand what best suites our small business. Any time we have a question the response is always done in a timely manner. I would definitely recommend Ovation to others.
Racheal Mumma: Update: Lora is absolutely the best! She definitely goes above and beyond helping me switch insurance companies. I am super thankful to know any issue that pops up, I know as soon as I contact her, she will get it fixed asap! Once again, top notch customer service wins again at Ovation!Original post: I like how I can email Amanda and she is quick to respond with whatever my question is! She is very helpful! This company definitely puts the client first. I've never had any issues! I would definitely recommend!
Tim Kiess: Haven't yet needed to file any claims, but I am pleased with the process of obtaining and updating my policies. Have always been able to get any questions answered without having to go through automated systems.

10. Amstutz Insurance - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 3 reviews

4105 W Jefferson Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN 46804

Address Website WhatsApp

11. Stewart Brimner Group - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 14 reviews

3702 Rupp Dr, Fort Wayne, IN 46815

Address Website WhatsApp

12. Tom Steckler Agency Inc - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 38 reviews

10432 Coldwater Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46845

Address Website WhatsApp

13. Cornerstone Insurance - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 4 reviews

6001 N Clinton St, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp

14. Auto Express Insurance - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 90 reviews

1614 St Joe Center Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp

15. Family Insurance Services - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 33 reviews

10327 Dawsons Creek Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp

16. Granville Insurance - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 11 reviews

1514 St Joseph Blvd # 100, Fort Wayne, IN 46805

Address Website WhatsApp

17. Ruoff Insurance, Inc. - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 7 reviews

1110 E Dupont Rd #1548, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

Address Website WhatsApp

18. Affordable Insurance Agency INC - Fort Wayne

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 3 reviews

6007 Bluffton Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46809

Address Website WhatsApp

add a comment of Insurance agency Fort Wayne

Comment sent successfully! We will review it in the next few hours.