Best Baseball Shops In Indianapolis Near Me

Webster's Sporting Goods Play It Again Sports DICK'S Sporting Goods Locker Room by Lids Avon Sports Apparel Corporation Play It Again Sports Play It Again Sports DICK'S Sporting Goods The Bat Cave Extra Innings - Indy South Indianapolis Indians Colts Pro Shop

1. Webster's Sporting Goods - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 27 reviews

5060 E 62nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Address Website WhatsApp
Webster's Sporting Goods: what do users think?
K. Michael VerKamp: The most helpful and resourceful sporting goods store, with a large variety of equipment, clothing, and even custom embroidery for your shirts and jackets. Locally owned and operated, and they truly care about meeting your goals. I'll keep coming back!
Matt Cassidy: So nice to get work done at a fair price and not have to deal with big chains on fixing gloves, etc. Mr. Webster got my catchers mitt fixed in just over an hour for 20 bucks. Not bad at all
D.W. Everett: Even though they did not have what I was looking for, the gentleman was very helpful and directed me to a place that did have what I wanted.
Mark Linton: This is a small business that everyone should support. Gentleman restrung my grandson's catchers mitt with improvements in an hour so he could participate in 5 games over the next few days. Great service and a fair price. I highly recommend Websters for personal service that reminds me of the small hardware stores of years ago.
Triston Smith: Enjoyed the "mom and pops" service and conversation.
Robert Coonce: Very knowledgeable, pleasant employees. Easy access from I69 plenty of example clothing in store. And even told us of things we didn't or wouldn't have thought of (adding future sports titles to jacket, ect). We have a younger child and will not hesitate to return.
Jennifer Niemeyer: Repaired baseball glove with quick turnaround and great quality. Very knowledgeable staff and extremely helpful. Great full service sporting goods store - hard to find places like this anymore.
Joe Gonder: Place is a joke drove over an hour to get there and tell me they cant do what I wanted done after the he told me on the phone that they can do it just drop it off..
Krista Armes: Very helpful and willing to go the extra mile to help!
Tom Hipple: In addition to the quality of the work reasonable lots of the price mr. Webster is a terrific guy you want to sit there and listen to him great stories and good insights
Monika Noel: I brought a shirt in to be embroidered on Wednesday and it was ready the next day. Did not expect this turn around. The people who work in this store are awesome and I highly recommend them.
Jay Williams: Great for custom jobs
Kevin Perkins: It a great place to take your goods to Embroidered or monogram the people have a real heart to help Serve you the best place in indy. Five star
Ryan Conley: Didn't have what I needed but was friendly and suggested another retailer.
Bobby Coffer: I had some patches put on a racing uniform and one of the patches was so crooked that I can't imagine how it could be overlooked. Granted, they gave me $10 off but how do you do that when you're in the business of embroidery, sewing, and iron on patches. Their attention to detail is terrible! We will definitely find another company to put the rest of his stuff on. They didn't even offer to redo it for us. Now we're stuck with a patch on his racing uniform that's crooked. I think Mike is the only person in the store that knows what he's doing. The customer service when picking up the uniform was horrendous. We waited in an empty store for 10 minutes and then somebody finally decided to come out of the back office. I would never recommend or ever use this company ever again. We didn't even receive an apology. Sorry Mike! Buyer beware!
Terrance Broadnax: Customer service is very detailed and informative of technology products you purchase
Phil Whitener: Great deals, local business
jamockio Andrews: Anything sports they have it
matt fugate: Great friendly service, took the time to fit my son with the correct helmet
amanda haley: Fantastic customer service! Mike waited until after closing for us to arrive and purchase a much needed item. Friendly, knowledgeable, and great prices. Highly recommend!!

2. Play It Again Sports - Marion County

Verified

Verified

· 220 reviews

8923 S Meridian St B2, Indianapolis, IN 46217, United States

Address Website WhatsApp
Play It Again Sports: what do users think?
Ruth Elkins: Play It Again Sports great place to purchase sports items.
chris holloway: Love This Place. The quality is always there. And the staff is always amazing. I highly recommend to everyone.
Johnny Schaefer: Why buy a used basketball for $50? Maybe if it was Larry Birds. But seriously, reconsider your price model. No used basketball should be more than $20
Evan Gehlert: I visit this place often because you just never know what you’re going to find. The nature of the store means it can be hit or miss but you can find amazing deals on high quality equipment.
Adam Stanford: Came in to trade a set of clubs in on a different set of used clubs. Called ahead to let the store know my intentions and to confirm the clubs of interest were still available. Drove 30 mins and was at the store by 7:45pm. They close at 8:00. I was told all trade ins stop an hour before closing. Would have been nice to know that when I called at 7:15pm and driving 30 mins. So I contacted the store owner and was told come back and we will give a premium on your clubs trade value. I’m told to allow an hour for the consideration and appraisal of my clubs. It took 15 mins, ironically the same amount of time I would have had to do that the night before. Ok whatever.So the two younger employees had no idea about the previous day experience or all the emails that were exchanged and nobody I had been emailing was there to speak with. Even though they knew I was coming to move along with this process by 3:30pm.We moved forward with my clubs and selling for credit towards another used set, which have a multiple day guarantee. I tried them out and found a couple of them with similar issues. I purposed taking my old clubs back and they can have what they sold me. I contact the store by email again and I’m told the issue is not performance related but I can return them if I wish, but my old clubs already sold and there is a restocking fee because they paid a premium on the clubs I sold them.Every retailer has the right to do business how they want. I’m just letting the public know to avoid getting taken advantage of here like I did. These folks are not interested in keeping a long business relationship with anyone. If they were, I would expect better treatment for the experiences I was given!
James Stevenson: Nice selection, helpful service.
PoHillBilly RedNeckery: Love this place, always helpful and knowledgeable. Great selection. Still a great place to shop.
Stan Wright: Awesome people to get very gently used equipment from.Thank you very much for the bike trainer we purchased today.
RJ Edgemon: Didnt have what I was looking for but they have a lot of nice stuff. Store was clean and staff was very friendly.
johnnie Cooper: Most things are at a decent price. Cool people as well
Seth Seaton: For our young daughters, this is the first place we go when we outgrow our sports gear and bicycles. Great selection and friendly people.
Neil Shaffer: Very helpful and good variety of new and used sports gear.
Konnie Singh: Very helpful! Highly recommended. Great customer service!!! 😁
Kendra Schinbeckler: The 2 fellas working were very helpful!!! Great prices and lots of selection! We will be back!
Bibiana Phillips: Guys in Carmel are nice
Britney Vance (Mongoose): do yall have gymnastics stuff??
Demon2 Hunter777: Speedy service
Cathy J: Very friendly employees. Very knowledgeable. Great prices.
Stephen Conwell: Prices seem high for used stuff
Max Woodbury III: Always has great equipment for cheap
family life schupp and Pruitt: The kid working was SUPER helpful!

3. DICK'S Sporting Goods - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 329 reviews

6030 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46278

Address Website WhatsApp

4. Locker Room by Lids - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 148 reviews

49 W Maryland St SPE21, 49 W Merchandise Mart Plaza Space 21, Indianapolis, IN 46204

Address Website WhatsApp

5. Avon Sports Apparel Corporation - Avon

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 53 reviews

7710 E US Hwy 36, Avon, IN 46123

Address Website WhatsApp
Avon Sports Apparel Corporation: what do users think?
DP Bailey: Go last name printed on shirts & was in & out in 10 min. I'm definitely going back tho bc store had more than I expected
Andrea Cowan: Always such awesome service! They are friendly & I always leave with a smile!
Nakia Bell: Love this place! Always able to quickly get something made that turns out great.
Deana Carter: This place is a joke. We ordered a varsity letterman jacket on December 8, 2021. ($389.67)and paid in full at time of ordering. At that time we were told we were looking at the first to second week of January is when it would be ready. On January 30th we were finally notified the jacket was in. I had ordered 2 patches- neither of which were ready. Fast forward two weeks the patches were in. The “softball design” (his writing not mine) patch was was done in a awful dark gold and had navy blue stitches. I ask for it to be remade in the actual softball design. (Neon yellow and red stitching- which the son agreed were the correct colors for softball design) That was February 28. He said he was reordering THAT DAY. (Keep in kind at this point her jacket is still just hanging on a rack) Fast forward to Saturday March 19th. Daughter goes in with another family member to drop off her varsity letter she earned and her jacket is still hanging in the same spot. Older man tells her they’ve been waiting on us and pulls out the dark gold and navy softball patch. She tried explaining. He gets hateful. Starts blaming us for his mistake. My adult cousin who is with her tries to rectify the situation and calm everything down. No go. Daughter calls me I tell her, you know what- forget it, get your jacket and we will go somewhere else. Old man refuses to let them leave with the jacket because we haven’t paid for the softball patch (she wasn’t taking it with her) and demands payment ($32) for said patch for jacket to leave. She pays. Brings jacket home - no patch and now I realize this is the shotty embroidery done on the back. Literally big gaps that have no embroidery. Oh and his varsity jackets have NO lining. They are made in Mexico and are literally the wool with silk fabric sewn in at the top and bottom. No quilted warm lining like every other varsity jacket has. We have shopped at this store for years- soccer stuff, athletic socks, shirts and apparel but never again will this man get a dime- and I’ll do my best to make sure no one else spends a dime in there. Go to The Locker Room in Danville or Team Sports in Brownsburg. And I wish I could give a zero.
Jake Watkins: Awesome service! I can always count on excellent quality and great prices.
Courtney Jay: My kids and I have purchased some of their custom “Avon” wear here and they love them! I also ruined an AJAA jersey in our dryer that they didn’t even make and they still fixed it for me same day. They are awesome and I will always send everyone here!
Aaron Poland: A staple of Avon and a GREAT family-owned business! Any time we need team stuff, we know where to go!
Dave Carrell: Great people did a great job!!!
Tim Toepp: They cater better to those that buy from them, they have a fair selection if your team buys from them. They will even add your number to the jersey you buy from them. Their prices aren't rock bottom, but they don't gouge you, you'll pay about average prices.
J. Cole: Great customer service, I will return again.
Larry Pridemore: This is the best place and the people are very friendly and help you with what you need
Jenny Stoops: Phil always goes above and beyond to make sure our uniforms are delivered in a timely manner, even when mistakes are made on my side of the order. The uniforms always look awesome and the quality is great. Avon Sports is super responsive and provides excellent customer service. They are my go to uniform provider. Thanks Avon Sports.
Matt Dodrill: Nice people
Ryan Dunfee: Phil has everything soccer related that you could ever need. He even carries referee essentials too.
Saboor Khan: Good prices and happy to support a local family owned business.
Richard Thomas: Everything we needed for kids soccer... the $40 package is WELL worth it
Quentin Smith: Great customer service. Clean and good location. Excellent quality sports equipment.
Scott Wagner: Always great service!
Chris N: Great Company! The customer service is top notch! I've had multiple orders now and their advice has been great! The product and service they provide is high quality and exactly what I've asked for every time. Very friendly, you feel right at home!
Gabe Blissmer: Great service. Good selection of soccer equipment.

6. Play It Again Sports - Carmel

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 102 reviews

2332 E 116th St, Carmel, IN 46032

Address Website WhatsApp
Play It Again Sports: what do users think?
art_canvas_brushing: Worst customer service there were two sales people at the store and we went there for road bicycle , the cycles which we liked were not tagged and one of the sales person was not known of the prices and attributes and the other one was really rude and dint want to entertain … we came back .. we felt insulted..
Geoffrey Breedwell: Staff was knowledgeable, friendly, and patient. They are some pretty chill guys in there. They even let us try the items on for a proper fit. Love this place. I only wish I had more money to buy all the things. But alas, I am poor.
Michael Smith: Clean and nice and helping employees
Tyler Brittingham: Owner was rude and acted like (me) as a first time customer returning a Christmas gift I should of known the history of the store. Then after being rude and not letting me return the weights to that location he offered to buy the brand new weights I was trying to return for half of their value. Definitely never going to that location again.
Jacob Phillips: Lots of options at great prices!
johnnie Cooper: They have loads of stuff at decent prices for about every sport.
Patrick Martin: Great for getting gear/equipment cheap. They have everything from team sports, to weight lifting, golf, disc golf, bikes and more. Always can get good deals and if you’re looking to save money then buying used from Play it Again is the way to go.
Chris Lombard: Have a good assortment of discs new and used. Great place to go if you're looking for multiple manufacturers. Drove a little bit out of my way to make sure I was able to stop here I was glad that I did.
Grace gracie: Definitely had great selection & service. Much appreciated! Thank You.
Nancy Kincaid: Their employee answered all our questions and was very cordial and professional.
dodgerjonesmd: Play it Again Sports is Awesome! Dan was great to work with and I highly recommend!!
Jay Burnett: Good merchandise good price staff is knowledgeable
Jeffrey dudley: Great service good prices
Jeremiah Tyson: Love this place! Lots of used and new equipment. They even have some harder to find disc golf discs!
todd tiede: Great selection of new and used equipment from baseball soccer weightlifting and about any other sport including cycling. Also have a great selection of golf discs and sticks and bags.Innova Discraft MVP discmania prodigy for a few.👌 Good selection and knowledgeable staff. Giv'em a look just 116 in Carmel...
Anthony Lomax: They have everything
George: Great service. And good selection. Highly recommend.
Jan Wingren: Went with my sons on Christmas eve and did some last minute shopping. Nice staff of kids and a very good selection of gear. I need new hockey pants and got a great deal. Hope you guys have a great 2022!
James Gregory: Original Review (2 Stars): I accidentally miscounted the number of used floor squares I brought to the counter (I had 7 but thought I had 6). Right after paying, I realized I had one more than I needed (yes, I should have been paying attention). I mentioned what happened to one of the cashiers, and the other cashier's response was "Well there are 7 there." Kinda rude. Guess I won't be back.Updated Review (5 Stars): After I posted my review above, the owner responded to apologize and to clarify what had happened. We communicated via email and he assured me that the situation was an anomaly, with which I agree. He did offer me a $20 merchandise credit, which I appreciate. However, I would have revised my review to 5 stars on the strength of his honesty and eagerness alone. He promised to review his store's return policy with his employees and apologized profusely for what had occurred. Again, that was much appreciated and the sign of a truly engaged business owner. I'll continue to visit this store for my used sporting equipment needs.
Jon Harrington: Lots of gear and very friendly staff.
LaDorn Wilkerson: Awesome place to shop. I go here to get all my sporting gear. From disc golf to hockey. They have a great variety

7. Play It Again Sports - Fishers

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 100 reviews

11681 Olio Rd, Fishers, IN 46037

Address Website WhatsApp

8. DICK'S Sporting Goods - Plainfield

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 358 reviews

338 City Center Cir, Plainfield, IN 46168

Address Website WhatsApp

9. The Bat Cave - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 9 reviews

8734 East 21st St, Indianapolis, IN 46219

Address Website WhatsApp

10. T2 Pro Gloves and Apparel - Greenwood

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 2 reviews

894 Cherry Tree Ln, Greenwood, IN 46143

Address WhatsApp

11. Extra Innings - Indy South - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 108 reviews

5545 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217

Address Website WhatsApp

12. Indianapolis Indians - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 13 reviews

501 W Maryland St, Indianapolis, IN 46225

Address Website WhatsApp

13. Colts Pro Shop - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 102 reviews

500 S Capitol Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46225

Address Website WhatsApp

add a comment of baseball shops in Indianapolis

Comment sent successfully! We will review it in the next few hours.