Best Insurance Agency Indianapolis Near Me

4worldlovers: Steffey Insurance has worked hard for over fourty years to build a business that puts its customers first and delivers first class customer service to all its clients. Representing countless carriers in twelve states, we have the products to provide the coverage you need and knowledge to back it up.


Listed below are several of our most common product offerings. We have many companies with a wide range of insurance options, so please ask if you're uncertain of our ability to insure you. Chances are, we can!


Liability, comprehensive and collision. Contact us to make sure you have the coverages you need.


Protecting your largest asset can be complicated, let us help you find the policy that fits your needs


Each business is different, and requires different types of insurance. No matter how small or large, our knowledgeable staff will find the solutions.

An umbrella, or Personal Catastrophe Liability, policy provides additional protection beyond your current insurance policy limits

Life insurance can add an additional piece of mind to you and your family

With the rising costs of healthcare, health insurance is as important as ever to protect you financially

Being in insurance for over 40 years allows you to develop niche markets along the way. These are just a few of the classes of business we specialize in today on a regional, or even national level.

We specialize in all forms of real estate including: apartments, condo associations, HOA’s, office buildings, REIT’s, student housing, and senior living facilities.

Whether it’s a software development company, app development, or cyber security firm, we’ve got you covered. We understand the nuances of these coverage options and how they affect your bottom line.

We offer a full suite of surety options including an instant issue surety portal found on our website homepage. Beyond this, we offer contract surety and fidelity solutions for all project levels.

We provide both private market flood insurance, as well as FEMA programs throughout the country. We have access to private flood markets not available to many agents.

We enjoy insuring new restaurants and bars almost as much as we enjoy frequenting them. We can educate you in the coverages you require while offering the most competitive prices from a large lineup of insurance companies. We’ve also began writing BYOB’s with their strong growth in popularity over the recent years.

For international companies, setting up US subsidiaries can be daunting, especially when it comes to insurance. Fortunately, we have experience in assisting foreign companies with their insurance needs in the US. We work with several companies from the UK and Ireland currently.

"When going through my checklist of things that I needed, renter’s insurance was at the top of my list. I wanted to be sure that I was covered in the case that something was to happen to my apartment or any of my belongings. In conversation with Thomas, he provided me a quote within just a few minutes. Not only was my quote affordable, but he was very knowledgeable about the policy, consulted me through the process and provided valuable information about my deductible and overall coverage. Payment options are very flexible and I highly recommend contacting Thomas at Steffey Hatoway Insurance for any of your insurance needs. "

“I’ve had the pleasure of working with Aaron Steffey on the recent purchase of home and automobile insurance coverage. Aaron was responsive, knowledgeable, and was able to provide a new insurance package at a substantial savings over my prior insurer. Aaron worked tirelessly to find the right insurance plan for my needs, and walked me through every step of the process. Aaron was particularly helpful in recognizing specialty risk needs and in scouring the market to find the right product. I am quite pleased with The Philly Agency’s work, and Aaron in particular, and they have earned a customer for life.”

“It was an absolute pleasure working with Aaron and the Philly Agency. We first moved to Philadelphia and knew no one. Aaron was able to navigate all of the nuances of the local market and set us up with a home and auto policy tailored to our needs. We will be expanding coverage with an umbrella policy, and plan to continue working with Aaron for years to come! The best!”

4worldlovers: If you are using a screen reader and having difficulty with this website please call (317) 887-2223 .

Life Insurance and annuities are issued by State Farm Life Insurance Company. (Not Licensed in MA, NY, and WI) State Farm Life and Accident Assurance Company (Licensed in New York and Wisconsin) Home Office, Bloomington, Illinois.

Deposit products offered by U.S. Bank National Association. Member FDIC.

The creditor and issuer of this credit card is U.S. Bank National Association, pursuant to a license from Visa U.S.A. Inc.

Pet insurance products are underwritten in the United States by American Pet Insurance Company and ZPIC Insurance Company, 6100-4th Ave. S, Seattle, WA 98108. Administered by Trupanion Managers USA, Inc. (CA license No. 0G22803, NPN 9588590). Terms and conditions apply, see full policy on Trupanion's website for details. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, its subsidiaries and affiliates, neither offer nor are financially responsible for pet insurance products. State Farm is a separate entity and is not affiliated with Trupanion or American Pet Insurance.

Pre-existing conditions: If you currently have a pet medical insurance policy, switching carriers or purchasing a new policy may affect certain provisions such as coverages for pre-existing conditions or deductibles already established under your current policy. Let your State Farm agent know if your existing policy has provisions that might make it beneficial for you to keep.

State Farm (including State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company and its subsidiaries and affiliates) is not responsible for, and does not endorse or approve, either implicitly or explicitly, the content of any third party sites referenced in this material. Products and services are offered by third parties and State Farm does not warrant the merchantability, fitness or quality of the products and services of the third parties.

4worldlovers: Having insurance isn't just about money, it's about having the feeling that you and your family are secure on a day-to-day basis. The good news is, Indiana State Agency can help when it comes to finding the best insurance policies for your needs.

When something unexpected comes up in your life, it can change everything financially. One of the biggest benefits of making sure you have good insurance is the fact that you don't have to shoulder the entire financial burden when you're involved in an accident or a disaster strikes your home. Instead, you get help getting back on your feet and taking care of things financially.

Insurance is also great because it eliminates a lot of stress from your life. When you don't have to worry about coming up with the money to pay for home repairs, a new car, or a place to stay, you don't have to deal with nearly as much stress in the aftermath of a claim.

While some insurance is optional, there are some types you have to carry if you want to do things the legal way. In the state of Indiana, you're required to have auto insurance if you want to drive. If you're paying off a mortgage on your home, your lender will probably require that you have home insurance. These are both important reasons to get insurance.