Best Magic Shops In Indianapolis Near Me

Bled “Bonkers” Sledlee: awesome shopgo there once a week to pick up boxes/sleeves but they have singles, mats, pins, tons of cool stuff. definitely deserve your business

Stephanie Mccurdy: My kids love this place we go here to buy Pokémon cards

Matthew Case: Came here looking for old Pokemon cards, wasvery disappointed. they had none.

Jacob Barnes: Great store and knowledgeable staff! Was getting back into collecting Pokémon and they've answered any and all questions and sold me some great cards at more than fair prices.

Nathaniel Rowan: Solid gaming store to go play at.. pretty quiet .. not a fan of the layout .. good selection .. comparable merchandise and prices as every other shop... ... friendly staff ..

Dylan Turner: This place is the worst Pokémon card store that you could go to. I highly recommend not trying to sell your cards there because I had cards that were worth over $100 and they wanted to offer me $.50. They know absolutely know nothing about Pokémon and they try to scam. You do not go to this place. It is a scam. The only good thing about it is you can buy decent cards for a decent price.

Issac Padilla flores: They will try to scam you!One of the employees was very hostile and upset when I caught him trying to sell me all commons at rares and ultra rare prices

Crimson: L StoreL StaffThey don't have a binder to look at, you gotta message a list on Facebook (absurd), not really beginner friendly. Staff always acts like they rather be anywhere but there, place never has music playing so it's completely silent.

Stasia Smith: Super helpful and nice.

Zachary Snyder: If I could rate this place a 10 I would.

Sammy Watkins: Literally the most disrespectful people I have ever met. I was in there a couple days ago and these idiots claim a Blastoise card I had was fake and tried to throw it away. Very lucky I didn't clean his clock.

Robert Sebastian: Great store, huge selection, but your staff has zero customer service skills. I know it's hard to find good help, but you have taken it to a whole new level. You are so much better off going to Comicbook University, or anywhere a place sells cards for that matters before going here.

Maxilian 17: Bought some figurines from this place. Employee's were super helpful plus they gave me a great deal on a bulk purchase. 100% would recommend!

maria playsss: He told me my cards were fake

Ty S: Honestly I really really like this store and generally everyone is in a great mood and happy to help. I would say that on my last visit to the store I was a little less then pleased with my transaction and service. I inquired about some Yugioh ots packs and was pretty much just told “we don’t sell those” and that’s fine if you don’t sell them but I sure would like to find a way to obtain some without having to order off eBay or Amazon, I would much rather buy from a local small shop. This is the moment where an employee should add more depth to the conversation and help me. Then after I spent a few hundred bucks the guy took my money, didn’t give me my change and then said have a good day 😅 no biggie cuz it was only a couple bucks but it’s more of the principle. I will still be supporting this shop when I can. It rly is the best shop for a Yugioh player/fan.

Tyler Spiker: Very informative staff, they are friendly, and they always have the card stock I need. Love this place

Jeff Gregg: I've been to this store several times and never have had a bad experience. I have sold and bought several cards and packs from here and actually prefer this store sfor the stock the have more variety then any store I have been to. all the people I have come in contact with has been nice.

Ashley Spurgeon: 10/10 best card shop for all your Pokémon or Yugioh needs. The staff is great and really helpful! Tournament side is great and comfortable

Marlin Grace: I really enjoyed my experience at Grandmasters. The employee who helped me was very knowledgeable and pointed right in the direction I need to go. Amazing store for noobs (like me) all the way to pros.. I will definitely be coming back! Thanks again for all the info!

D P: Awesome card shop. I've been two times and I always end up walking out with a bunch of stuff. Staff are nice and friendly, helpful, but not standing over you pressuring you for a sale.Whoever the store clerk that rang us up today, I didn't catch his name, you're awesome, and thank you for giving my kid those two pokemon posters, he was so happy about getting those.Overall awesome store with fair pricing. Definitely a good card shop for TCG and things alike.

Karissa Stichter: It's a fun store with a ton of fun games and an area to play, too! The staff is knowledgeable and kind and a pleasure to talk to when you make your way in. Directions to the businesses in these areas are always a little off, but once you find it it's much easier to get back for your next visit.

Alichia Wilson: Love this place for games and cards. The owner is very nice and willing to show people how to play games. All employees here are very friendly and willing to help out customers. One of my favorite game stores.Update:Still love this place. Go quite often

Monica Murphy: Very friendly and knowledgeable staff.

Outlandish Matt: Great store. Stopped in to look for a card but unfortunately they did not have it (they have their inventory online) but recommended other stores that may. I would highly recommend stopping in.

Jonathan wright: Always come here when I visit my family. Great people and friendly.

Brennan Joseph: Went in looking for a deck of many things for my dnd game. Owner was incredibly rude, with a holier than thou attitude. I've been to this store multiple times, and my experience has been consistently worse every time. Do not come here.

Jenny Abbott: They were very nice and helpful. I found a few different items I have not been able to find any where.

Zure: Extremely friendly and accommodating staff, good vibes, and nice areas for playing. Highly recommend!

John Mosley II: Great store and helpful staff and players

Robin Prince: Yes!

CJ W: Nice place fun to play mtg at

Chad Bradley: Absolutely terrible service. These people have no respect for their customers. I would recommend going to any other company.

Jeremiah Sheffler: First time customer. Owner & staff are super helpful and friendly. Made our visit very enjoyable for my son. Gained a regular customer.

Lil B The Based God: Has a pretty expansive collection of cards that I've purchased from for years. I will say this place is not where you want to go to sell your cards. They will buy your cards as heavily played with a piece of "dirt" on the back (you could scratch it off-I did with no damage to the card) and then sell it as moderately played for 3.5x what they offered you. Other than that, it's a great store that I enjoy coming to and playing magic with friends.

Milton Ginebra: This seller is acting strangely about online sales. There is a ton of buyers leaving negative reviews with the same issue I am facing. They claim they had thousands of orders during the holidays, are not equipped to handle them and we are supposed to feel bad. With all the money they made they could hire extra help. All they did was create the USPS label online (to get paid) but after three weeks have not handed off the package to USPS, this is clearly a scam. Stay away

Allan: Good selection for Skirmish wargames. A few nitpicks: it was dimly lit, they had me enter the price of my order into their POS system which was strange, store was pretty disorganized, and my online pickup order never reflected the fact that I actually paid and picked up--it just eventually got cancelled.If you're just trying to play MTG or Infinty these things don't matter, but if you're introducing new people to your hobbies these are all a turn-off.

Whamo Blamo: Very nice homely location for table top stuff and magic card singles, staff was beyond friendly and welcoming

Kurt Davis: Absolutely wonderful game store. Owner is an incredibly friendly guy who will answer any and every question you may have. Highly recommend this to anyone who wants games.

Noah King: My go-to game store. The people here are incredibly friendly and inclusive, and very eager to please! I'd recommend this for anyones board game/ tabletop needs. An awesome selection and they're always getting cool things in. 10/10

rainyday 2316: Super friendly will go back again

Kaoe Hikaru: Friendly staff, good layout and wide selection of games. Good playmat collection to choose from as well. Good selection of cheap magic bulk.

Dr. William Starsiak: Great game shop in downtown Indy

Joe Fields: Pretty much the only place downtown you can go and find TCG goods. Nice selection of dice and other accessories, they carry last year or so of sealed MTG. Singles section is a little thin. Will be stopping back in when downtown. Staff is excellent.

Josh Winters: Great game store

Nicolas Howell: Good amount of space, good selection. Can fill up quickly for larger events, but people are friendly.

Joni Heredia: Shout out to Sable and Good Games. They are extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Went there to buy/sell Pokémon cards, and I also saw that the store was super clean and organized. They sell singles and everything else Pokémon, Magic, and of course, games. There is plenty of street parking. I highly recommend you stop in with your friends and family.

M. Martin: Stoked to find all the Pokemon we ever wanted downtown, plus extra happy the staff was so cool to my kids.

Bradley Summerlot: A cool store. A little high on some singles and low on others. Just watch it.

Nav Loveday: A cute game shop in the heart of downtown. A great selection of table-top games and accoutrements. MTG cards are sold here. There are also some tables set up in the back area. Staff is friendly and helpful.

Jordan Beasley: No other business in the area would let my wife and kid use the restroom (even as paying customers!)These folks gave us kindness when we needed it. My daughter picked out and bought her first set of polyhedral dice while we were there, and she calls them her "treasures" and is enjoying them right now. Thanks folks!When I come back for Gen Con or to see family again, I will stop by!

Ryan McCall: A friendly staff and a bit of everything. Well worth a stop in

Tunsin: I love this store with all my heart, it has things from all the franchises I like, and it’s a great place for likeminded people to come together.

James Crosby: Buy far one of the best game stores in the USA. As a trucker I travel an have been to many especially in the whole middle of the country and this store had just about the works. Trade in values was amongst the best I've seen as well as the prices was fair. Solod 5 star for exceptional customer service Eric one of the store managers was amazing! Highly recommended checking these guys out. There MTG single selection is vast just use there handy kiosk instore or go online. Not to mention they're literally center downtown on the strip of Indianapolis! 💯

Deion Conley: I brought in over 50 cards for trade in, they got me in store credit for them at a good price. Super chill and easy going staff.

Josh Lemons: Amazing selection. Great space with helpful people.

Gene Lane: Friendly staff, good deals to be had, and cold drinks.

Friday Austin: Really cool shop!!

chamar folson: Cool store of boards games!! Vintage and new board games of all kinds some games I've never heard of

Thomas Leung: Very friendly and welcoming staff

Austin Whitehead: Great game store. Gencon pre-event was fantastic

Brad Urban: Favorite shop in Indianapolis.

John Doe: Workers sometimes rude and inattentive but otherwise good selection of cards

Will Senefeld: Called and asked if they had Scarlet & Violet prerelease boxes and was told they'd have them available for purchase all day. Drove there and was then told they only had 30 for sale and you had to buy them before their event. If you have an extremely limited quantity and restrictions on when you can buy, let your customers know so we aren't wasting our time and gas. Will not be returning.

Keith Doran: Jeremy is alright I guess

Brady Gilbert: If you value your time. Highly recommend going elsewhere. Paid over $400 on cards- over priced. Came back a couple days later. Just to see what they would say, brought in $1500 of my own cards as well, they offered $50. Another note, if you want deals/cheaper items go to Moonshot in Noblesville. They overcharge on everything. Build and battle display they want over $250 even though TCG has them at $148, which is who they came to go through. Their employees also know nothing about card conditions, if a card has a bend they think it's LP. Lol, this company has become a joke among many peers.

fracZ BioHazardZ: Great customer service and nice people but $16 for a whole entire box worth i gave them isn't worth $16. I had alot of bulk cards that were worth more than that all together even cards that were holos from old packs were included towards them just be given $16. I could've sold some of those cards for more

Justin Clement: Sometimes it is excellent customer service but the last time I was there I had to wait 39 minutes just to buy a booster pack

Nicholas P.: Magic players rejoice! I have never seen such a diverse collection of booster boxes in one place before. Perfect for chaos drafts or if you're looking for a particular older set. Plenty of singles to browse through as well. Aside from that, the store is very clean and well organized. Plenty of other TCGs, tabletop RPGs, and board games. The only thing I could ask for is a larger board game selection, but their focus is obviously geared toward the TCGs. Would definitely love to come in for a tournament one night. The staff was also friendly and extremely knowledgeable.

Michael Vack: Some counter people are good but most are terrible. Put in a list with them for them to tell me they didn't have half the cards on list which I understand happens. But issue came when while waiting in line found over half the cards they said they didn't have in the cases which to me felt like they never actually looked. They sell foreign products at American prices but will buy cards from at foreign prices.

Zachary Wade: Thanks so much for the customer service. I usually get profiled really hard walking into these shops but I was welcomed with open arms. Genuinely thank you.

Mason Hiatt: Super nice guys! Big selection of magic cards as well

Davo Olson: Awesome! Lots of Pokémon products! One of my new favorite places! I will definitely be returning!

Victor DeBolle: Smaller selection than most stores but staff is friendly

Aaron Kirk: I wouldnt even give this place one star, he k not wven a half a star. They absolutely low ball every buylist they come by, including mine. Which includeo a new double masters dockside extortionist birderless, force of negation borderless, wrnn and six, and countless others. They offered me 230$ for all of em.Makes it even worse when i accidentally left all of my most valuable cards there on accident, which a bunch are missing from. I mean they had my phone #,why not call me to let me know i jad left them. Very sus place, dont go there if ur selling

Brett Davis: Walked into the store for the first time and will never come back again. Wanting to play commander using their tables. No events going on at the time. Have never gone to an lgs and been told you can't use their tables to play casual.

Sophia Groeschen: I originally had given this place a 5 star, but recently my experiences here have been rather so so. Their selection in terms of Pokémon cards (singles) has been minimal and I will more than likely stop selling cards in here overall. I recently brought in numerous expensive cards that I had priced via tcg and was looking to see what I could get for them, all NM, one was a $60+ card, they offered me $20, one was $207+, they offered me $160 which I wasn’t too upset about, one however was $260+, they offered me $150!! $150. For near mint. There was others as well, but long story short definitely didn’t sell them lol. I do NOT recommend bringing higher end cards here if you’re looking to sell, I’d sell my bulk here and stick to selling my independently. I used to love this store and they’ve always been great, but as of my past few visits, I’m not too happy with my experiences. Not sure what changed honestly.

Glide: I didn’t feel welcomed to be there, seemed annoyed that I was selling cards, took my cards in the BACK of the store to check them, and was left to dry while they went back to opening card packs with their friends.. not to mention a lot of their prices on sealed product are marked up like crazy.

Nicholas Wise: This is one of my favorite game store for Magic: The Gathering and the occasional army painter accessories for my miniature painting. All the employees are cool and never make you feel like they are judging you with a sense of superiority. And the prices are reasonable. Plus the rewards program can't be beat.

Robin Sypult: Went in with my son, since he has mastered basic board games like monopoly and life and all. I asked the staff member for a recommendation and he took alot of time telling us about various games until we found one WE LOVE!!!! And they have a great selection of Pokemon cards, which my son LOVED! I'll be going back for sure!

N3gus Wulf: This place was horrible!!! Visited with a friend and owner was extremely aggressive and pushy for me specifically to leave the store as everything I touched “was not for sale” they followed me around the store and refused to even let me look at the items in the store. Bottom line this business discriminates on color I will never shop here