Best Second Hand Clothing Stores Indianapolis Near Me

The Toggery Resale Boutique Newman & Co. Indy Thrift Queen Clothes Rack Mission 27 Resale Plato's Closet Style Encore Greenwood Plato's Closet Indianapolis Mission 27 Resale Naptown Thrift Thrifty Threads Goodwill Store The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center Broad Ripple Vintage The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center

1. The Toggery Resale Boutique - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 116 reviews

1810 Broad Ripple Ave Suite 4, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Address Website WhatsApp
The Toggery Resale Boutique: what do users think?
emily: My favorite spot in Indy to shop for clothes (and even some home decor)! There's a great selection, I find the prices are usually reasonable, the items are in great condition, and the staff is really friendly. I visit at least once a month - often more than that - and more often than not leave with something!
Laura Franz: I was happy they were open on New Years Day - appreciated that. Staff were not welcoming/friendly although they were well- staffed. I found one wonderful item but won't be back. I would suggest going to a straightforward pricing system - trying to match the sale tag colors was distracting.
Jules Gallaway: Absurd prices for branded clothes that aren't nearly valuable
**: Meh 😐
Audrey Paoletta: I LOVE this store you can find every brand in your size for such a reasonable price. I’ve gotten so many designer things from here for a fraction of the cost and it’s all basically new. Good thing I live close to this store because it’s my fav and I won’t shop anywhere else!
Alex Cravens: such a cute shop. found some great pants. Has some unique finds at decent prices.
Cecelia Staab: I love this gem of a store. They have great sales and very friendly staff
Angela V: Love this place.. very friendly staff... Lots of sale items and selection... Unfortunately if you are sized XL or larger there is not much for selection. Last time I went to the toggery I was a size medium/large and scored a ton of wicked clothes on the cheap... Post 2020 pandemic I am now an XL and didn't find much I'm afraid... But seriously tho... They have a large variety of clothes... Once I'm back down to a solid large I'll be back and buying their clothing with a vengeanc.. cause yea they really really do have awesome clothes here!
Clarissa Laws: Visited this shop while visiting Indianapolis, and it was delightful! Fun, diverse inventory and reasonable prices.
Judy Brooks: Excellent experience friendly employees great prices...Awesome jewelry. Black and white necklace and bracelet picture does not do show justice of these beautiful peices go into the store designer shoes clothes and purses ..They also do consignments you will love store ...
Bear Lee Fitsin: Decent selection of pieces. Customer service needs tons improvement. Promotions they market online aren't made aware to walk in customers.
Jennifer Dueweke: My daughter enjoyed all the consignment findings, especially the Lululemon! Big, clean store. Busy, in a good way. Will definitely be back!
L S: Thats a nice and cheap place, a lot clothing options
Alex Nieuwland: Excellent store. Mainly women’s fashion, but I found a nice jacket in my size and a silver ring for my beautiful bride. The staff were very friendly and helpful.
Linda Merritt: Great consignment store!!
stacy matheny: Great stuff and friendly staff.
hiawathia 1: My go to spot for thrifting. I always find fashionable, unique gems. Ive been a customer since the old location in Broad Ripple Village.
Veronica Banks: I hadn't visited The Toggery since they sat off the canal in Broadripple. My neighbor and I had an awesome time!!! Plus the employees were soooooo friendly!!!
Tami Holland: Meh!
Shelley West: Love this place, great selection and good prices
Melissa Myers: We loved this place and will definitely be back! Well-organized, clean, friendly, great items, and really good prices!

2. Newman & Co. - Marion County

Verified

Verified

· 133 reviews

720 E 65th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Address Website WhatsApp
Newman & Co.: what do users think?
Kyle Bush: Highly recommend...I have been shopping here for a few years now and they keep getting better and better. Great quality name brand men's clothes, suits, shoes, apparel and accessories. Like-new/gently used at a fraction of the cost. Now they are carrying home decor and furniture. Staff is incredibly helpful and friendly!!'Brother' store to Amanda's Exchange.
Kelia: A fine selection of men's clothing and accessories all of which are in great shape. I loved the boutique atmosphere and it's convenienly right across from The Cake Bake Shop.They have suits, dress shirts, hats, shoes, etc and changing rooms available for you to try items on before you buy.
Brian Taylor: I love this place. Great clothing in great condition for second hand. The staff is great too. Very helpful. They have taken my information and let me know when they have something that I have been searching for.I highly recommend them for quality clothing at a very reasonable price.
Eliska Jonck: Had an amazing experience here with my hubby. The staff went above and beyond. When we asked for help, they helped with a smile. Not once did we feel judged or out of place. That is rare nowadays. So thank you to the staff here for being helpful. Their prices were amazing and the store was clean and well kept.
Kim Workman: Excellent merchandise and great service.
Roberts BBQ: Staff is extremely rude. I went in to search for a few vacation things for my husband, I was never greeted, never asked if I needed help. I then asked one gentleman if he could point me in the direction of Tommy Bahama clothing and he just pointed and continued talking to his co-worker. I walked out at this point and won’t be back. Try harder guys!! A simple “Hello” when someone walks in goes a long way!!
Pierre Britton: Great spot
Adam Oliver: First off, the place has great clothing that is high quality for a fantastic price (50-90% off retail)! Then, the place is simple and laid out very well, easy to shop. When I walked in, I was greeted and when I said that I needed a rental, the clerks got Dominic to walk me through the process. He helped me pick out an amazing outfit for half of a suit rental that looks amazing and fits me great! I will shop here again!
Allie B: What a lovely store! It was very neat, organized, and tidy which made for an enjoyable shopping experience. The staff was very friendly and helpful. I popped in to consign a suit and was helped immediately. We'll be back for future purchases and consignments!
Robert Bishop: Great Cloths and Items.
Chris Carpenter: Great men’s consignment shop. This has existed in the area for a long time under different names and ownership. They now do home decide items as well.
Daniel Martin: my favorite place to shop! great brands, like new, but super low cost ✨✨
Blake Flowers: Top of the line used products.
Zach Stock: Great deals, and a great place to sell your gently worn clothes.
Ed Rivera: Men, if you need business casual and formal wear, check this place out first before getting anything custom. This place is cheap and forever a first stop shop for business attire. I have gotten so many dress shirts that fit perfectly from here. Don't take my word for it, check it out for yourself
M Hall: Passing through for sweet eats and spotted this gem! My tall husband found plenty. There may be a few vintage items but this place has on-trend, name brand, quality, like new selections in an array of sizes.
Larry Taylor: Great selection, pricing & informed staff..always find a great bargain!
Alfred Weems III: I always enjoy the selection and quality at this consignment store. The shop has now added furniture to purchase.This place is always phenomenal!
Tim Moore: Excellent selections, service and prices!
Tim Gruenhagen: Best used men's clothing store I've ever been to. If you are my size please don't go so that I can snag the good finds, otherwise please go and support this awesome business.
Mark Wells: Nice selection of men's clothing. Always neat and clean. Staff were courteous and willing to help. I will shop here again.

3. Indy Thrift Queen - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 0 reviews

6346 Colonnade Ct, Indianapolis, IN 46237

Address Website WhatsApp

4. Clothes Rack - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 25 reviews

3121 Thompson Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Address
Clothes Rack: what do users think?
Becky Davis: I have purchased a few things from here, I take items every few months and I’m happy with the money I make from the items sold.
Emily Jacobs: I stop by here every time I'm in the area! Norma and Darlene are the sweetest ladies! I always find good deals, and the quality is amazing, she never puts out anything not up to par. Worth the stop.
Dawn Merrill: You never know what you'll find!! Grest shop chock full of clothes and house wares. Norma and Darlene are super nice too.
Carrie Mcgoon: Very beautiful store 😍❤
Claudia Renick: Fun place to shop. Always find something.
jodi davidson: Friendly atmosphere...great prices...close to home...love this place
Jeanne Giuliani: Love this place.
Julie Lange: Have been going here for 20 years. Such high quality things at very reasonable prices! Norma and Darlene are the sweetest!
Debbie V: She has so much in such a small space! What’s gem of a consignment shop!
Janet Jordan: Great little shop with something for everyone. The owner is a jewel.
Donna Sebren: I always find something that I like when I shop here. I enjoy it even more when Norma is there. She is so pleasant to talk to. Good quality items.
Michelle Madding: Stopped in here on a whim. Great quality items, great prices. The lady working was very sweet and friendly.
Linda White: found a nice pair of slacks for 10.00.like new
Steven Jackson: Its ok
Sonnie Verhines: my cousin recommended this store but I have stopped 3 times and they are never open what are the hours
Catherine Salinas: Great consignment store know Norma since my kids were little her & Darlene Sherwood are great !!!
Mr Brink: Great inventory. Reasonable prices
Sheryl Harris: Can find some awesome clothes, jewelry, shoes, purses
April Kennett: Name brands and great sales
Mary Tepp: Every time I go there I find quality pieces at great prices. Today I bought a pair of brand new slacks, brand new sweater, 2 wrap sweaters, a pair of gorgeous new Jen's, and a pearl necklace. The total was under $50! And the staff is awesome!
Carol Shaw: Very nice stuff and even plus sizes. The lady in store is very nice. I found a brand new vera bradley purse was a great price.

5. Mission 27 Resale - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 153 reviews

1618 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203

Address Website WhatsApp
Mission 27 Resale: what do users think?
Ruben Cabrera: Great clothes, always clean. Just wish they had an associate at the counter at all times. Sometimes I've had to wait for someone to attend me.
Daniel Jefferson: I ended up buying clothing housewares a new table a couch that furniture to the clothing that they have been there is amazing and it's dirt cheap.
Rico Salcedo: I like it a lot more then Goodwill
Tyanna Messer: I like this resale shop they keep things organized. They also have pretty decent prices and quite a few name brands.
L Scott: Very friendly and helpful people. There's even a little coffee shoppe inside.
Jennifer Moore: We love this thrifty shop, always something new to see. The money raises gives to St Vincent Death Paul Pantry and programs
Sandra Bryant: Extraordinary finds
David “D-Ray” Davis: I shop here A LOT. Good prices and it's for a good cause. And good people work there too. This place is what Goodwill should be but isn't. Love the Mission Store!
Jessica McKamey: Great!
W.T. S.: Usually have good things that you might need, cleaning supplies, dishware, furniture etc, prices have definitely gone up though but that applies to all thrift stores these days since it's increased in popularity.
Mare Bear: my friend and i stopped in for shopping and coffee, we both got lattes made by a worker named Alo, they were delicious and she did an amazing job making them! 11/10 service, thank you Alo ♥️
Nick Damptz: Nice place clean good lighting overall nice resale shop. Pic of some vintage chairs
Darrel Poppino: The prices are a bit high for a thrift shop and about the same as another welll known one. Fun to browse though.
Steven Riddle: Awesome and cheap finds. 5 🌟
Amy Harris: A little more pricey than some thrift stores, so don't expect the rock bottom prices. However it was clean and had a nice selection. They also have a coffee shop.
Lisa Patterson: Sooooo many nice options to choose from on gently used furniture, clothing, and household goods. Must try!!!
V: Oh the poverty that lent itself to my 'discovery' of this cornucopia of lotions, household chemistry, dishes, clothes and furniture!!
Desiree Walker: I always find a deal when I shop here!
Jamie T: *# Check Mission first when you're buying household supplies! #*Mission doesn't just have clothes and they're different than a goodwill.Mission has new products like spray cleaner that they source from Target and Whole foods. Product availability in store changes often so I like to check what they have before making a trip to a big box store. It's definitely saved me some money.
mosquitos the Beast: Ay buenas cosas
Bev Marcum: The ladies were very friendly and helpful when I was there. Clean place.

6. Plato's Closet - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 308 reviews

7775 US-31, Indianapolis, IN 46227, United States

Address Website WhatsApp

7. Style Encore Greenwood - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 151 reviews

7657 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Address Website WhatsApp
Style Encore Greenwood: what do users think?
Natas Drol: The owner of this business talks to her employees like dogs. I personally witnessed her yelling at her employees over her bad day and talking down to them in disgusting ways. I highly doubt she pays them enough to warrant that treatment. I won’t be returning and I’ll be informing everyone I know to do the same. Disgusting.
Shawn Hicks: I am a woman who used to be employed there unfortunately only because I got an interview with no vehicle. It was the only option. The so called manager Michelle is very passive aggressive and two faced (what woman isn't really?) also childish to where it's embarrassing!!! She caters to the staff obnoxiously, acts like a chicken with it's head cut off, says very inappropriate things, shares too much, and doesn't stick to her word. Need I go on? Yet she wants to buy the place?! I don't see how? This place had SUCH an odd energy and I was highly uncomfortable. All I wanted to do was scream seriously. The floors don't get vaccumed and the staff don't try to go above and beyond like they want to believe. Pretty rude really. Lastly, the shirts will have stains and be charged over $10. That is not right at all! DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME HERE FOLKS!!!
Rachel Gephart: Overpriced used clothing
Kat Marie: Love this store!
Amy Hoerner: They have some decent stuff but their prices aren't that great
Beth Stewart: Reasonable prices. Quality clothes and plus size selection.
Sharmon Lee Russell: I'm never disappointed with my shopping experience here. Great deals and awesome rewards program!
Susan Buckel: Super friendly staff. Top notch service. Great deals! Awesome manager! Highly recommend!
John Damman: This place is amazing!
Krystal Thom: Michelle is amazing! She is always very polite and helpful when I come in. I absolutely love shopping at this store!
Vickie Dillon: Frankly they don't even deserve one star. I went to Style Encore on 10/24/22 was told I could only get $6.50 out of a brand new pair of Fila Ray Tracer's, because they weren't supply selling well. These have only been worn to try them on.This is the second time I tried Style Encore. I took a whole bunch of shoes last year and was told they were to old looking. I came home and find three of the pair of shoes in a catalog I had just received.
Virginia Morgan: I got so many things! I can go places in real clothes now!
Debbie Wright: Friendly, professional staff. Great selection for casual and business attire. A little pricey, but great selection of name brand items. Big selection of boots and tennis shoes.Today 50% off a large selection of fall/winter clothing. Weekend sale clothes marked down to 60 and 70% off.
Jen B: They have good quality used clothing. Prices are more than Goodwill but less than the mall.
Tina Ringness: What a waste of time to take good quality clothing in and wait only for you to buy 2 items. After looking around your store, you probably should view it from someone other than a teenager’s perspective.
Shannon DePouw: I walked into the store with my mother and 2 women (1 in her twenties, the other women older) looked up from the counter and continued to do whatever they were doing. As they were BOTH still standing at the front counter “looking busy” we were checking out all the purses. Mid you we both had a purse in our hands ready to buy (1 coach, and 1 Kate spade) we continued to walk throughout the store, up and down all the aisles. Both women went down an aisle to hang up clothes and STILL no contact. Therefore we walked up to the counter Neither women were up there and sat the purses on the counter. The young women (nice) asked if we were ready to check out and I politely said we were but we were ignored and not greeted by the other 2. And we left the building, as we were leaving the mid twenties women had a smart A comment. Needless to say I won’t be returning or giving money to a store like that. Very disappointing as I had a coach purse that I loved.
Wonder Twin: Would be nice if they would update their list of the things they're buying online before you lug totes and totes of things in. And just know that they don't buy all the popular name brand items
1st Rocky: This store is great! I had no idea it was there after an unsuccessful shopping trip for a special occasion, my daughter then told me about this place. Its now definitely going to be my go to place for any upcoming shopping trips 🛍 ☺️ I got just what I was looking for, the staff were great and the prices were shockingly low! I would definitely recommend Style Encore to all!
Mark A. Barmes: My wife Shelby loves this place. They are very particular about what they buy, but they explain clearly up front what they are looking for. But the upside to that is you know the inventory is the best.
Abbey: The women who work here are so welcoming and nice!! Very clean store; the pieces of clothing are like-new and stylish business casual styles. Highly recommend the Greenwood location!!
Danielle Hogue: As long as Michelle (manager) is there I have zero issues with this place! I've been in here quite a few times - two of those times she has been there and I have sold quite a bit and she is super friendly and helpful....the other times she hasn't been there I've gotten attitude from employees/employees being rude or they just don't even actually look through my stuff (and it's painfully obvious) after having it for a long period of time. I actually voiced some of these concerns to Michelle yesterday and she actually listened to what I had to say and made me feel like my concerns mattered! The new employee working with her seemed promising as well!****SIDE NOTE FOR THOSE WHO DID NOT KNOW THIS INFO (I WAS INFORMED OF IT YESTERDAY): This company amd other affiliated ones are supposed to be like "stair steps". Meaning it starts off with kids stuff at Once Upon a Child, then clothes for teens to around the age of 24 is Plato's. Clothing geared for 25+ is Style Encore. Style Encore also has a ton of inventory in different storage which is making the people in charge tell them be more selective about what they'll buy from us. It's not the employees just being picky just because (at least not all the time).

8. Plato's Closet Indianapolis - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 394 reviews

9391 Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46229

Address Website WhatsApp
Plato's Closet Indianapolis: what do users think?
Henry Rodriguez: Overall it was a ok experience. Good place to go if your looking for good gently used name brand clothing.
Danielle Hogue: The people who work there always seem less than friendly overall...I will say once in a while the customer service skills are on point. I, along with tons of other people, have the same issue though with this location that I have with the Greenwood & Westside locations as well - they expect all clothes to come into them clean/folded/neat but EVERY SINGLE TIME you get your containers back they are wadded up/wrinkled/messy.
Sandra Davis: Nice selection of size XL
M Augustine: If I could give -100 I would. Crusty. Dusty Musty. AND THEY STOP BUYING CLOTHES AT 4pm? Normal people are still working then? Makes sense since it looks like everyone here survives off EBT and section 8. Gross.
Duane: I took my friend she here she loves this place .I never seem to have any money when I am here.
Miranda K: My daughter found some great jeans and a pair of Vans here. The staff were nice and the racks were stuffed full of clothes. Prices were very reasonable for what we were looking for.
Tyrone Baxter: There ok
Ronmel Kraudy: Excelente lugar por las ofertas
Karissa Farrington: Called yesterday before I drove 40 minutes away to sell some NWT clothes no one mentioned that they were not buying today. Will not be returning to this location
Miranda Shipley: The staff are nice an the store is always clean an full of nice clothing
Sophia Hall: Glad I went.
Jones Gordon: Definitely a place to stop by and check out.
Tiffany: Rude service received here last year. Brought in a ton of stuff to sell and they yelled as soon as I got in the door, "No trash bags!" I have never heard of this rule at other Plato's Closet locations.
Domonique Coats: The pricing the sales the staff very friendly mainly the prices are bomb 💣 and selection
Neb Freely: It's a pretty good Platos Closet. Some things are full priced like some of their Jordan's. But found the wife some brand new looking Jordan Air Force 1s for $30 n a pair of Rock Revival jeans for $20. Now she's happy, so I'm happy :D
Christina Robertson: Over priced
Shaela “Money Baby” Mederios: Very clean store
blepsandbeans Jace: Clean store and found what I was looking for!
Devon Rachelle Carter: Love this place . Some things are over priced but worth it most the time. Workers are always helpful and nice
Cleverly Lockhart: Purchased some great items, fair pricing.
hi person: My 19 year old daughter always gets great deals here. She got 1 skirt, 2 shorts, 3 tops, and a pair of brand new boots for $50.00!!! Many clothes are new with tags still on them.

9. Mission 27 Resale - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 388 reviews

132 Leota St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States

Address Website WhatsApp

10. Naptown Thrift - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 34 reviews

2174 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Address Website WhatsApp

11. Thrifty Threads - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 103 reviews

1501 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260

Address Website WhatsApp

12. Goodwill Store - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 248 reviews

5640 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241

Address Website WhatsApp

13. Boutique On The Boulevard - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 4 reviews

531 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203

Address WhatsApp

14. The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 135 reviews

8310 Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219

Address Website WhatsApp

15. Broad Ripple Vintage - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 205 reviews

824 E 64th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Address Website WhatsApp

16. The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center - Marion County

Not verified

Verify

Not verified
This business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.

Request your free profile now
· 101 reviews

725 Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Address Website WhatsApp

add a comment of second hand clothing stores Indianapolis

Comment sent successfully! We will review it in the next few hours.