Best Cheesesteak Restaurant Evansville Near Me

lyn davis: Terrible and over priced

Shanna: We LOVE this location! Staff is friendly & restaurant is super clean. We would love to eat here more frequently bc it is ALL delicious, but so expensive. $20 for 1 combo meal is so high, makes it tough to take an entire family to regularly.Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes Fresh-Cut Fries, Sub, Chocolate Chunk Cookies, Cheesesteak …More

steve miler: The food was excellent. The staff was fast and friendly. Awesome experience 10/10Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Mary Bahe: Tom & the Chef were AWESOME & Friendly!

Lana Mays: Great food and very friendly staff! They were seriously understaffed and didn't let that get to them, our cheese steaks and fries were some of the best we have had at any Penn Station. They deserve a raise!

Alyssa Donnell: Always amazing customer service! Never had an issue! I eat at this location quite frequently anytime I come to evansville. Food is very consistent and I've never had a long wait. Very clean and stocked location!

Jordan O: Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 4/5More

Matt Evans: The employees are always a highlight of the experience! They do a phenomenal job!

Jeremy Skelton: Had great service from start to finish The woman that took our order was very helpful. The sandwiches and fries were made perfectly. I tried to stop at half. But I couldn’tVery good job ! Can’t add a photo. It’s gone 😂

Kip Fulton: Drove 50 miles to eat Penn Station cheese steaks! Passionate about Penn Station!Food: 5/5|Service: 4/5|Atmosphere: 4/5 …More

Khali Sinnett: I came in 10 minutes before close and these guys were amazing and friendly! Great customer service and the sandwiches were awesome! Wonderful experience will most definitely be back!

Humble G: Thomas my guy great vibes and energy G

Rebecca Tilley: Chad would not give us our paid for sandwiches and was extremely rude. Argued with my husband and told him it was our fault we couldn’t get the sandwiches. Chad said we ordered though GrubHub. Jim showed his our order and receipt that both said the oder was for pick up. Chad argued with him even more. I called GrubHub and they called Chad and told him he was wrong. Our order was for pick up. Penn Station, you don’t need this person representing your company.

Julie Bailey: I walked in a requested something of what I thought might be kind of odd but the 2 guys working on tonight were so nice and accommodating. My salad that I ordered was so delicious. I wish I would have gotten their names. But they did a great job and great customer service!!

Joshua Thomas: Dine in: YesMore

Scott Meyer: New crew is amazing, very friendly.Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes Delivery: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes …More

J I Gomez Zea: The best pizza sub.

Jacob Majors: Dine in: Yes Takeout: YesMore

None Required: Seriously cost me $17.10 for a medium sandwich small fries and small drink. Never again. I could have had a full steak dinner at Texas roadhouse with 2 sides and free rolls for less. I can believe the pricing here. Not even close to worth it.

David Patterson: Good place to eat.

James Penland: Not a Philly cheesesteak at all.

josh Enlow: Very good I'll be back againFood: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Tara Hughes: Awesome Philly cheese steak

J N (JJstyle05): Sandwiches are always exceptional. If you like crinkle fries these are hands down the best in town.

dennis Utley: Great service

Kerry Holtz: Very good 👍 ! The Philly Steak cheese is great !

Michael Vaughn: Steak sandwich was delicious

Chris Render: Love the little philly

Deborah Blackford: It was fine.

Ted Mitchell: Sunset Crews is a lot of fun. Line is long at the bar so buy two while you're there!

Lydia Hoops: I paid $65 for my food and couldn't get any condiments without paying. When you pay that price for food condiments should be free.

josh berasi: 11 out of 10 awesome wings and Philly

shannon bradley: Here's my review. The Philly cheesesteak was delicious. It's served on a hoagie bun that is soft with light toasting. The crinkle fries,sorry Shaun, were cooked well and not greasy. I also ordered fried mushrooms. They aren't like Frontier's or Rockport gas station, but still good. They were crispy and fried well. The horseradish sauce that came with it was good and not over powering. I came mid afternoon pretty quiet in here. Tea was fresh. They have tvs but no sound. It would be a good place to come and eat with a date and be able to talk and hear each other. Thumbs up from me.

harry potter: Good place to eat lunch there

Dave Swan: Excellent cheesesteaks!!

Super Woman: So we went about the 11th of Feb. TEAM WAS 5* Quality cooks had masks on. Very friendly and knowledgeable about pricing and ingredients and answered all our questions. We said we are definitely coming back! Cook asked which meat choice any sauce... etc...***We were impressed!!!!***And here we are it's the 15th of Feb. Came to dine in, super excited. Seemed like this girl didn't want to be at work! Not very welcoming. No questions asked and not thanked at all.... different cooks... No masks... now how is this possible in such short time. I will hate to come by and having to check who is working because we are not coming back to this... 1st Team absolutely and would given 5 ***** but today's... not sure if we want to come back.

Curtis Hustace: Love the Philly grill. The sandwiches are great and they have really good wings!

Lana Mays: Best Philly outside of PA! My husband is from Reading, and we have a favorite sandwich shop there. He also lived in South Philly for awhile, so he knows his cheese steaks. The Philly Grill's cheese steaks are very similar in taste and the bread is really good! He also ordered mozzarella sticks, and were some of the best we've had. The fountain Birch Beer was also a plus. We will definitely be back whenever my husband gets homesick!

Frank Readerman: Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: YesMore

Brandie Wilson: So good

Kelli Garner: Love this sandwich shop! Perfect everytime.Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Ashley Hazelwood: Every charcuterie board I have gotten has been beyond my expectations! They are so easy to work with and the staff are lovely. It was windy today when I picked up my board and they even offered to carry to my car for me. All the small touches to the board really make this a conversation piece for a party. I would give more than 5 stars if I could.

Mona Harmon: Enjoyed the vibe of the restaurant and definitely loved the food. We have had the Godfather, the Nona, and the Ham subs, with all different variations of veggies and toppings. Delicious every bite! This was our 2nd visit and there will be many more to come. Siciliano Subs Satisfies your hunger 😍

Anne Brummett Devlin: Excellent Cuban subs. Thumbs up.

Charley Beth: hands down this place makes the best sandwiches 10/10

Michael Jackman: Food: 4/5|Service: 3/5|Atmosphere: 3/5More

J Memmer: Solano’s subs are the best!The muffaletta is absolutely delicious! I highly recommend having it during Mardi Gras celebrations.

chris white: I can't believe I didn't find this place sooner. Definitely the best sandwiches in Evansville by far. Also staff very personable. I told the guy making the sandwich if the food taste 1/2 as good as it looks I will be back. They are going to get tired of seeing me. Thanks guys*updateNo longer the same owner or the same experience. The guy behind the counter cursed pretty much the entire time I was waiting for my food. I wouldn't bring my kids in here.David, you should have taken the name with you when you sold the business.

Lonnie English: This place COULD be awesome. I like the small business feel of the place.The problem we had was the portion. WHERE'S THE MEAT?!? I had the Godfather and wife had the Cuban.The taste was good on her cuban but it was just mustard and pickles, the meat and cheese were unfindable. I like my Cuban pressed flat but this had so little meat and cheese it was about a ¼ inch thick. My Godfather was the same, I opened the sandwich and it was very thin sliced meat and cheese, one single layer that was so thin you couldn't taste anything but bread. For $30 for 2 sandwiches and 2 drinks I was expecting a sandwich like pictured on the reviews, meat on it.Disappointing experience, as I said could be good if they put some protein on it. Flavors were good but all I tasted was the veggies and sauce on both sandwiches.Didn't take any pictures but the place is a cool small hole in the wall. Just need to make sure quality control is a little better, $13 for my sandwich and it had less than 3 ounces of meat and cheese total on a footlong.Vegetarian options: If you don't want meat or cheese, this place is great. Not a sandwich shop if you want meat on it.

Shelby Gardner: Fantastic food and service, for both regular lunch and catering events! The food was not only delicious, but beautifully and creatively put together for our specific event. The staff are so detail oriented, communicative/flexible, and dedicated to giving you the best possible result. Highly recommend!!

Eric C: Food: 4/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5More

clyta Lunsford: Great place to eat!Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Raymond Senior: They make it just the way you want 👌 I didn't feel like I sandwich and they made it into a salad, I had the Cuban. It was delicious. I would suggest you go if you are hungry.Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

D B: Very nice and friendly people working there. Really good food.

Brittany Monroe: Delicious. Probably one of the best sandwiches I've had in a while. Make sure you get the "shakeys" on your sandwich. Definitely worth it. Very friendly staff. Highly recommend.Recommended dishes …More

John Small: Thats what I call a SUB! Thank you Jess, Chris and Bub!

Jess Ehm: Friendly service and fresh subs!Vegetarian options: They have a vegetarian sub.

Frances Jones: I've seen great reviews and finally decided to try it this past weekend. I got the nona. Friends got the Siciliano and the Cuban. No complaints about any sandwich. Price- similar to any other place for sub sandwiches. I will definitely be back! Support Local!

Michael Fisher: Heard this place was great so I went to give them a try. Ad says they're open but at noon on a Tuesday they are closed. Not a good first impression.

Kristina Setzekorn, Ph.D.: Great sandwiches.

Jessie Marshall: Absolutely amazing food and exceptional service. The two gentleman who assisted me were friendly, had great personalities and made my experience top notch!

Rob Nunley: Luke gave me a good experience. He was friendly and engaging, even changed my grumpy mood. Would of gave 5 stars but the lemonade was sweeter than expected, but Luke was gonna make a new batch.

Mike Mason: Great subs and serviceFood: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Jamie Runyon: First time.. the subs were very yummy.. the service was excellent and fast… cheesesteak and classic Italian is what we had along with some of the best fresh cut fries I’ve ever eaten!! They were perfectly cooked and crispy 😋 Would definitely go back to this or any other location to try some other flavor subs and to get more fries!!

Jared Magie: Travis C is the best salesperson I've ever met! His incredible energy is infectious... One of the best experiences I've ever had with a franchise representative in my life!Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes Fresh-Cut Fries …More

jungwoo lee: So dirty!!!Employee teeth so naughty and decayed. He was talking whole time while he was making sandwiches and spits went into my sandwitch. I couldn't eat sandwiches and had to throw away..

Susan Clouse: Recommended dishes Chicken Parmesan, Fresh-Cut FriesMore

Jack Rietman: Tom served us, and it was amazing food, and amazing service 10/10 experience.

Mary Bahe: Tom & Chef were Extremely Helpful, Friendly & Professional. Food was Great!😃 Turkey Bacon Ranch on Sourdough..👍Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Janie Allen: The food was delicious and the staff was very friendly. We enjoyed the atmosphere.

Julie Witherspoon: Wasn't very goodFood: 2/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Brooke Dimmett: It’s been several months since the last time my husband I ate here. Last time was absolutely awful with horrible customer service. They gave us two coupons for free sandwiches for the awful experience. We finally went to use the coupons before they expired. We were greeted by Kendra. She was so kind and apologized for the bad experience we had previously, even though she wasn’t there at the time. She took our order and the cook, Luke, overheard our story. He also came up to apologize for the last time we ordered and made sure our food was correct this time. The food was delicious and the staff was incredible! We’ll definitely be back.

Kristin Fields: The staff was beyond friendly and provided great customer service. The food was great and fast! Tom was the man!

Natasha Cain: Great customer service! Made a great Philly cheesesteak and super excited about it. Luke and Tommy were amazing and personable and accommodated my crazy request of cutting and putting in a bowl for better storage. Will definitely return next time I pass thru.

Florentino Morales Jr.: Great service and delicious sub! Good combination 👍Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich Missing the Lettuce and Tomato …More

Claire Peacock: Very friendly and great service! Of course the food is amazing too!

Astar Taylor: Sandwich where terrible mangers needs more training employees can’t read tickets not weighing up food Rt this was one of three time I’ve had a bad experience here will never go back to that location.

Ashlea Gruner: Penn Station on N Burkhart has the best service I've ever had! I appreciate their hard work ethic and great work ethic at their store.

Tess Harper: Serenity was awesome! Very polite & our order was perfect!Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5Recommended dishes Chicken Teriyaki, Philly Cheese Steak Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot …More

Edward Pfaffel lll: Great place.Food: 5/5|Service: 5/5|Atmosphere: 5/5 …More

Todd H: I haven't checked out Penn Station in quite a long time, so I decided to give them a try Friday night and ordered online. I set a pick-up time to be ready in an hour for three sandwiches and three orders of fries.Sandwiches were ready to go when we arrived, and the fries were already cut and just needed to be cooked. Took a couple minutes, but I definitely appreciated the fresh fries.The sandwiches were all excellent, and there were zero complaints from my family. I will definitely be visiting this location again in the future.

S.b.b Mikel: Don’t go here sat in there got 15 mins never got acknowledged had an order for pick up . Never going to penn station again

Andy Hinkle: Good food but small club sub, small fries, and a small drink was $14. Far too expensive for a quick lunch.Edit: They replied for me to fill out a form on their website to pass to their store manager. That's not how this works. This is my review and it's your opportunity to figure out how to pass it to the store manager.

Fern: I walked in and there were already people complaining about the food off to a great start. The people working there start complaining about the people that were arguing about the food we ask them to politely stop complaining and they don't stop. They just start ranting about how we asked them to stop complaining about the people. Once we actually got the food they forgot the fries truly the worst dining experience and very unprofessional2022 update-I was tryna act like adult in this review I was like 11 or 12 💀

Adam Howe: Delicious! Friendly staff

John Heil: Someone please come here and teach them how to clean there tables, etc....🤯😬

Shannon Austin: Extremely unprofessional staff. Answered the phone with "hello" instead of the name of the business forcing me to ask if I had the right number.Switched staff on the phone mid order.Come across very incompetent and unconcerned.

Larry Sisco: Good food, just expensive!

Nick Austin: Philly cheese steak with onions, mushrooms, mayonnaise, and pizza sauce. Seems pretty simple, right?Not for these guys it's not. They've managed to get it wrong the last 3 times I've ordered it, and 4 of the last 5 times. When I called to speak to someone about it she was insanely rude and uncaring.Prices are outrageous and can't make a simple sandwich correctly. Sad.

Tracy Crawford: Great food

Augman331: Very good sandwiches and not at a bad price.

Connie Smith: Good sandwich but not my favorite. Less meat than I like etc.

Angela Trout: I waited 10 minutes for my food after I called it in. My sandwich was coldCurbside pickup: Yes …More

Joshua Hazelwood: When I order online, it always takes about 10 minutes longer than the website tells it'll be ready. The employees are nice, and everything is hot and fresh.Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes …More

Noah Howellstone: Awesome store great food clean restaurant a little expensive but other than that yum

Timothy Gray: Great

Joseph Hortin: Yummy