Business in Bakery:
ADD MY BUSINESS
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Candy store
1. Sweet Schmitt's Candy - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 29 reviews
422 N Main St, Evansville, IN 47711
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Jacob Hoefling: Owners and employees are great! I love their candy too!
wd willis: Nice selection of tasty candies
Terita: The Butter Pecan Clusters, oh my! Delicious!! Just received my order and will be ordering more! So glad that you ship to Alabama
Michael Williams: Great selection of supplies and very helpful
Joe Jung: Great candy
Daniel Thorbecke: Hands Down the BEST CANDIES AND CONFECTIONS IN EVANSVILLE, or anywhere in the tri-state area. Mike (owner) and his wife are the sweetest people. You will enjoy your visit, or order online and get in the club. 5STAR all the way.
Daniel Griggs: This candy shop has amazing candy and its good prices to I highly recommend you going there
la Jones: Great candy every time!! Super nice staff and very clean store!
Kindra Long: This place is so nice, so many HOMEMADE candy’s and not overpriced!! The couple that owns this place is also so sweet and nice. Would highly recommend stopping by here
R R: nice friedly staff
Travis Methena: I got a box of these delicious candies from a co-workers baby shower and they were great! Made me look up the store and it's not far from the house!
Sarina Winterrowd: Great local shop with homeemade candy and very friendly owners/staff
Nancy Bock: I ordered my boxes of candy and then stopped in a bit later to pick them up. I could of waited, but had an appointment i had to get to. When I picked them up - they were perfect. And an added bonus - they give away free coffee! They have a keurig so you can pick from tons of flavors. I got cocoa - being in the sugar spirit.
Proud Anachronist: One day I was walking around the N.Main part of town when a nearby event I participated in was finished, and I randomly stumbled on to this store. Had never heard about until then. What a wonderful surprise! It's a local mom-and-pop business in a part of town that has some old world character, and they make and sell one of my favorite things: chocolate. Very courteous employees. By the way, the candy tastes great also.
Patricia Adkins: Love your Sweets. My favorite is the Cafe Mocha Marshmallow. Delicious
Julonda Carawan: Sweet Schmitt's is a spectacular shop!! Love how they connect with you, and their carmels and sweets are amazing!
Abdul Sunny: If i could rate this place more than 5 stars I would! Great people! Great sweets! Great Prices! The Chocolates and Caramels they have are amazing. The people behind the counter are incredible. Their prices are fair and they have a loyalty program that rewards you for buying sweets! We will DEFINITELY be back for more!
Terry B Jackson: I like the richness and uniqueness of the candy. They really carved out their own niche. It's much different than traditional store-bought candy.
Kourtney Woracek: Have yet to be in the store - never knew it existed. Was brought some of the delicious sweets to work and they were awesome! Will definitely swing into the store and pick up my own sometime.
Rita Goodall-Hulsey: Oh my! I never thought marshmallows could taste so good!! They are wonderful & so many different flavors to pick from! The nut clusters & different flavored caramels are soooooo good too!! Definitely recommend!!
Bella Bearr: Sweet, delicious, and perfect ♡♡♡
Verified
Candy store
2. Stephen Libs Finer Chocolates - Evansville
Verified
· 336 reviews
6225 Vogel Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
Address
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Candy store
3. Old Fashion Candy Co. - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 39 reviews
2546 Eastside Park Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Jessica Brooks: Very nice people I got introduce to. Nice to know there really there for the kids and schools functions in the end if you think about. And my interview didn't last long at all.
Deborah Lindsey: My daughter is employed there.
Janice Wright (Broccoli for Breakfast): The candy sells itself. They have an excellent selection and the chocolate bars sell exceptionally well. A great way to raise funds quickly and easily.
aaron wright: Old Fashioned Candy provides an excellent product that sells well and produces great profits. My family has used and continues to use their products to fundraise for extra curricular activities.
Tameka Amado: Affordable and great selection of candies. I even liked the bonus surprise (you didn't hear that from me). Will be ordering from Old Fashion Candy again!
Benji man (The Money Saving Dad): Thank you Old Fashion Candy! Our candy bar sale was a huge success and it was fun! The chocolate sold itself just like it did when I was in school...selling these same delicious bars! Fast and easy ordering and shipping...which is practically free! They give you free stuff to cover your shipping charges so you don't eat into your profits. They are just a great company all around.
Desirae Ransom: This is a great company to fundraise with! Ordering process is super easy and we receive our candy within days of placing the order! We have used them for our Middle School Drill Team for 2 years now and haven't had any issues!
Erik Carlson: Great selection of candy, great prices, and it shipped quickly. This really helped us with our fundraiser.
B LV: I love Old Fashioned Candy Co!!! I use them for all my fundraising needs. The customer service and fast delivery are only a couple of the reasons why I turn to them! Their products are delivered in great shape and if there are any problems or discrepancies, they handle it promptly. Why go anywhere else??? I'm a customer for life!!!
Jesse Dewane: I am currently a customer of this wonderful fundraising business. They have a specific person help you with the details of your order. This is a great company for any fundraiser.
Kaitlyn Chinn: I have bought many times from this company! Its absolutely great for fundraising and has good quality and nicely prices chocolate! For my next fundraiser I will be sure to buy from here! The packages came quickly and the customer service is great! Definitely 5 star worthy to me!Kaitee C.
Nicole Lawless: shipped very fast and sold very fast, has an amazing taste. will definitely order again.
Sylvia Whitehouse: We needed a fundraiser for the American Cancer Society and discovered Old Fashion Candy Co. online. They were easy to work with, I placed the order online and had more questions and all my emails were answered quickly! The Chocolate Lover's Bar fundraiser was perfect. Everyone loved them and the price was perfect! We will definitely use this company again next year for our fundraiser !
Tasha Ford: We love the different ideas and variety that they offer for us to sale to raise money our organization.
Y R Cooper: I like working with this company and my orders come on time!!!!!!!!!! I will be starting my fund raiser soon with them. I can't wait to get started!!!!!!!!!!!!
Lee Ann Brophy: This company is great for fundraisers big and small. I usually order a case or two at a time. Not only does the product come very quickly, they include extra merchandise that you can sell to cover the shipping cost. Love this company!!
Denise Valentin: Our church was looking for a company where we could have different varieties of items that we could meet the needs and preferences of a wide range of clients and we were able to achieve that with Old Fashion Candy. They not only meet our needs but were able to provide us with the items we needed in a timely fashion. You are receiving quality items and get great profits. The items were received in a timely matter and were not melted. If your are a religious organization or any other type of company looking for a reliable company for a fundraiser I recommend Old Fashion Candy they have really met our needs.
Brock Renfrew: Great fundraiser idea! Fast shipping and great product mixes that sell fast. Highly recommended!
Trent Grove: Good assortment of product. Sells it self. Grandma's cookies are the best sellers. Would like to make up our own assortment.
CrossTimbers PTO: This is a great company with great products! We always sell out of the chocolate roses! We have used them for years! We will use them again this year!
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Cake shop
4. Creative Confections Boutique - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 2 reviews
820 N First Ave, Evansville, IN 47710
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Related inquiries Bakery:
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Chocolate shop
5. Mike Libs & The Chocolate Factory - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 79 reviews
864 S Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Jeff Woford: Sadly, closed forever. We were in town for a funeral and needed to pick up some dark chocolate pecan flip overs for a fellow chocolate lover. We went in on Saturday, February 25th and the shelves were 99% bare. They said it was their literal last day to be open. My wife had been going there since the brothers Libs broke up decades ago. Thanks for all of the chocolate and hopefully Stephen's shop remains open for decades more.
wd willis: Pecan flipovers are the best ever. Milk chocolate are delicious, but I prefer the white flips.
Sheena Shreve: Love their candy! Great family owned business!
Kelly: Chocolate was melted and unedible. I called to fix the problem. I was told they weren't responsible for melted chocolate. I was under the impression they woild ensure the proper steps to prevent this from happening. There isn't anything on the site about not being responsible for melted chocolate.
CHINOS YT: They have a very neat inventory and amazing chocolate. I got the chocolate chunk with caramel. It was perfect. I also got a bag of taffy good prices and a great and neat store
Don Annis: Pretty good chocolate in many forms to satisfy your cravings. I liked the chocolate covered coffee beans.
Jill Zueck: What a cute chocolate shop! Employees were very friendly and even offering samples!! I got Raspberry Truffles and Dark Chocolate bon-bons! Their chocolate covered toffee and caramels are amazing will be back for those! A must visit if you come to Evansville or if you have never stopped by. Something for all budgets!
Cody Cantrell: Got my girl chocolates here for vday. She loved them. Prices were pretty high in my opinion but what do I know about making chocolate?. Walnut clusters A+
Jackie Ost: Came To Late, My Fault!! Out Of White Choc Melt Aways & Milk Choc Raspberry Creams But Did Get Milk Choc Melt Aways & Milk Choc Maple Creams😋... Be Back For The Other 2 When You Make More.
Amy Padgett: Using the original recipes from Libs Candies, Mike provides a nice selection of chocolates and other favorites.
Brenda Roberts: Very nice store.
Van Haas: Mike and staff are always friendly and candy is great 👍!
Eileen Korba: Excellent candy
Ned Gibson: Everything was very expensive. I would’ve loved to have had a tour or a demonstration of how the chocolate gets made or anything with the process of their business. Didn’t seem like they did that (or at least, they didn’t when we were there.) Suggestion for future if not already done!
undeadlegion: Good customer service. Excellent choice of candy
Carol Birch: Not impressed. Messy. No public restroom.
Andrea Boberg: Freshly made Easter chocolates! Nice variety and they were still making them today. Mike Libs is probably the Easter Bunny's best friend!
D Noff: Probably one of the true legacies of Evansville. As a kid could watch the taffy pulling machine in the way back main Street. Glad to retain this unique tradition. Love the pecan flipperovers..( Not turtles)
ntnjobs: WOW! Just got a box of chocolate pecan flipovers in the mail, and these are simply the best chocolates I've tasted since I lived in Evansville. I'm going to put in another order now and send them to all my friends for the holidays.
Carla Thelander: Jerry here,Just got my Christmas order. Now for the discipline! Succumbed to the peanut brittle. Thanks Mike!
Sadie Nardini: Five stars!! I've been enjoying Mike Libs' chocolates for years. The sea salt turtles are out of this world!! I live in California now, but I'm originally from the Midwest, and I have to say, there's nothing like homemade, handmade confections that are from a master like Mike. They taste better, and I think, make a more loving gift than something big box store-bought. Thank you, Mike Libs! Can't wait for my next shipment! ~Sadie
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Bakery
6. GaylaCake - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 163 reviews
320 North Main Street, Evansville, IN 47712, Evansville, IN 47711
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Kathy Armstrong: Always delicious
Bill Loveall: Absolutely love their cupcakes, cookie, and other desserts. The staff is always friendly and best part is supporting local.
J B: Overall wonderful experience
T Fisher: Very sweet owner, staff, and a super clean establishment. I have enjoyed their sweets on many occasions. Nice to be able to support local businesses. Gayla Cakes is affordable for most budgets. The staff is courteous and you are greeted at the door. This establishment is a local gem. I can't say enough about them and their business. The cakes, cupcakes, and more are absolutely wonderful. I have tasted everything but their regular cakes, which I imagine to be just as wonderful. I usually get their cupcakes. The owner is personable and delightful. She works hard to keep her business afloat as small businesses are struggling right now. I will always support and patronize this establishment. I wish good things for them. This is why it is important to support your local businesses. If you have a sweet tooth and are in the local Evansville area; please consider marking this on your list of things to try. You won't be disappointed.
Taylor Jeffries-Glaser: Ordered a baby shower cake from them and was so in love with how it turned out. It was yummy and adorable. So affordable and great customer service also. 👏
Brianna Gatewood: Choose a peanut butter cake with chocolate ganache for our wedding day and it was sooo good! They also delivered it to my venue for a small fee and put the cake topper on for us. We received the top tier of our cake for free and got a 10% off coupon to order another cake on our anniversary! Super impressed! I highly recommend!
Melissa Turpin: Great cakes and cookies.
Dominic Poggi: Amazing cupcakes. Carrot cake was a favorite but they were all great. You can tell they use quality ingredients in that first bite. Staff is efficient and friendly. Pro tip: warm them up in the microwave just before eating. 25 seconds for one in my microwave was perfect.
Angie Swearingen: GaylaCake made my son's cake for his Eagle Scout Court of Honor. I showed them my vision, and they made it happen! AND the cake tasted FANTASTIC!! We had so many compliments!!
Brittney Moseby: As a local wedding photographer I see wedding cakes just about every weekend & my favorites are always when Gayla makes them!! Stunning AND delicious is hard to come by. I’ve also come to know her in passing & she’s the sweetest lady! She obviously takes a lot of pride in her business.
Cindy Sullivan: cream horns, cupcakes - sooooooooooo very good!!!!
Jessica Mitchell: Was quick and easy to order 36 cupcakes of many varieties for my daughter's upcoming bday! Even though they were swamped I was met with smiles and attentiveness during my visit. Can't wait to pick up our cupcakes in November!! Thank you GaylaCake 😊 💓
Sus Temple: I keep coming back because of the delicious cakes and cupcakes and especially the super friendly service as soon as I walk through the door. Cakes are so moist and fresh and the icing is amazing!
Darla Turpin: Gayla Cake has made everything from a wedding cake for our daughter, cupcakes for a special birthday party, cream horns (so good) and cherry turnovers for my husband, and cookies just because they’re delicious and we needed some! So if this reads like everything is wonderful there, it is! What a great local bakery! ♥️
Shantae Ferguson: I’ve birthday cakes and cookies from here, and they were always delicious! The staff here are very nice and friendly. I even go in store once a month(because I’m dieting lol), to purchase cupcakes. I love the cookies n’ cream cupcake, but I’m a peanut butter lover! So I hope there could be a peanut butter cupcake sometime soon😊 I definitely recommend Gaylacake for all your sweets!
Amy T: Run, don’t walk, to Gayla Cake to pick out some delicious treats to meet your every need!! This is my go to bakery for quality products, affordable pricing, and glowing customer service. Everything I have ever purchased has been absolutely delicious! The chocolate chip cookies are the best in the world! All of Gayla Cake’s employees go above and beyond to serve their customers with kindness and excellence. Love hearing how this business loves and serves our community so well!
Alyssa Tomes: Love GaylaCake! We used her for our wedding and again for my baby shower. She didn't offer a certain type of dessert we wanted at the time of our wedding so she worked to create something special for us so we would have what we wanted. Everything I've had has been wonderful and the prices are very reasonable!
Kendra Bisesi: Absolutely love this place! We have ordered custom cakes and have stopped in for a special last minute treat. Everything is super delicious and I have always loved every part of the experience. Gayla cake should is a must try!
Lora Taylor: I love, love, love their cream horns and gooey bars. I don't like driving out of my way to get there to find out that they have 9:00am as their opening time on their website and its on the window open. But they don't open until 10 unless you have an order. So that's why I'm taking a star off. Change your website so your customers don't waste their gas and time.
Sarah Dauer: The perfect cake for our celebration! We ordered a custom cake for a baptism reception, and it was perfect. They were very helpful with the options and details, and ordering and pickup were easy. I sent a picture of the baptism invitation, and they created a design to coordinate beautifully. The cake was a specialty order to be vegan and it was delicious. 10/10. We will partner with GaylaCake for our future celebrations.Edited to add 2nd review. Repeat customer, repeat 5-star satisfaction. After the excellent experience with a precious baptism reception cake, we knew we’d return to GaylaCake for our next celebration, a second baptism reception. Again, ordering was easy, and they were timely and responsive to questions and details about the cake. We sent the invitation for design inspiration and they created a beautiful coordinating cake design. We ordered late and they were able to deliver with a short turnaround time. The cake flavor was outstanding. We ordered more cake this time, and still none was leftover. We continue to be so pleased with our GaylaCakes.
Heather Hurt: So happy with my daughter’s birthday cake. It was so pretty, delicious, and ready when promised! Friendly and very helpful staff. Affordable pricing too!
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Bakery
7. Just Rennie's Cafe & Cookie Company - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 3 reviews
102 SE 4th St, Evansville, IN 47708
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Wedding bakery
8. Piece of Cake - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 192 reviews
210 Main St, Evansville, IN 47708
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Bakery
9. Panaderia San Miguel - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 191 reviews
2004 Washington Ave, Evansville, IN 47714
Address
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Bakery
10. Crumbl Cookies - Evansville - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 2725 reviews
939 N Burkhardt Rd Suite B, Evansville, IN 47715
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Bakery
11. Be Happy Pie Company - Evansville
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 118 reviews
2818 Mt Vernon Ave B, Evansville, IN 47712
Address
Website
WhatsApp
