Best Domino's Pizza Evansville Near Me

Jeff Jackson: First time I have had there pizza 🍕 in years and it was pretty good

Cassandra Ainsworth: I ordered a make your own thin crust online. Alessandria made the pizza beautifully and Jerry, the delivery driver was very polite ! The pizza was very good !

Devin Bohnert: App and website say the store is currently open, but doors are locked and not a single employee in sight, on a Saturday evening too.

Holly Wood: Most of the staff is kind. It's clean inside. A good Domino's.

* Crawley: Slow, Cold and RudeThose are the main principles here.They NEVER answer the phone.Order from anywhere else but here.

Terri Seaton: We ordered sandwiches and a black guy and girl was fixing it. The sandwiches was horrible. Then on February 11, 2023. We ordered again the same thing happened again. Hard sandwiches they need to improve. But I lost money. The food went into the trash.

GraciouslyFalln: We ordered two pizzas and the new bacon and cheese tater tots, and everything was hot fresh and super cheesy. We wanted something different other than a bread side and getting the tots was the right choice, worth a try for me.

Delores Finley: Good foid good service thanks

P Carlisle: Had great pizza and was done at time told.

Dustin Broughton: Delicious pizza, friendly staff, timely service. Thanks

Neph Jones: The pizza I ordered in Wednesday night was delivered me without being cut and the dough was raw and not cooked. Very disappointed

Deb Gilchrist: Had to go in to order my online account wouldn't go though people inside were great had my dogs in car just had surgery they were nice enough to bring pizza to my car

Bryon Loren: This place is awful .. signed up for curbside and I sat outside there door for almost 10 mins . ended up going inside and getting my pizza ask about there curbside and was told uh were to busy ... Got home and the pizza was so greasy I couldn't eat it .. I tried for 3 days to call this store no one EVER would answer the call . Would give negative stars if I could

Osito: Forgot part of the order on top of the fact that the delivery guy dropped the pasta order and it spilled put the round container and into the box. To finish it of they took for ever to answer when I called to ask about the order.

Dumb Games with Shiki: I ordered food 10 minutes before the closed the said they'd deliver, it went through 4 steps and they canceled it, now I won't eat tonight.

Mya Oconnor: 100 times better service then weinbach dominos

Lee Riddle: Constant issues with this stores delivery service. If the food wasn't late (which it often was) then it would usually be missing a sauce. Frustrating when these sauces have an upcharge attached to them. Wish Domino's would let you choose what store you wanted delivery from.

Bethany Wilhite: This is a good Domino's. I've never had my order wrong, the toppings are put on evenly, and they are extremely fast. You won't regret ordering from them.

Shawn: Arrived 2.5 hours after the order was placed (I live 2 miles away), and it's not even what I ordered. At least this location is consistent with it's trash delivery times.

james copeland: WORST SEVICE EVER ! WORST

Dustin Lehman: I ordered wings and normal cheesy bread at 6:20pm. I didn’t get my food until 2 hours later at 8:30pm. I found hair in my cheesy bread which was the wrong cheesy bread. This place isn’t punctual nor is it sanitary

Sky M: Shouldn't take over 2 hours to deliver a pizza... I'm still waiting and the pizza tracker says it's been done just no one is delivering it smh.

Tiffany Haggard: Quality of food is USUALLY average, occasionally subpar. Wait times avg 15-35 minutes longer than app predicts. Nobody answers the store phone, ever lmao

Vincent Torres: It's been ok

Ben Moore: LOST A CUSTOMER PERMANENTLY!!!!! 4 ORDERS IN A ROW MESSED UP. Today, I ordered. After 30 mins waiting, they call to tell me, "we don't have a driver. We cancelled your order" Pathetic pizza place

Serilda Tafflinger: We just ordered pizza and our driver rocked for driving on these icy roads! Pizza was great!

Janine Scales: Always so friendly

Mario Moore: Love the pasta

Jennifer Mason: Worst service ever. 3 hours later and have not received my order.

Matt Matt: Excellent

Shaileigh Crane: Pizza toppings was slid off of one of my pizzas as if the pizzas was dropped & then my cheesy bread was hard on the outside & undercooked on the inside !! Been on hold for 16 minutes now !!

Mya Oconnor: Stood there 10 minutes everyone looked at me but didn't help me

Jeremy Lucas: Absolutely trash service. Waiting over 4 hours for a delivery less then a mile away and being sworn at when called out. Pickup only or do yourself a favor and go anywhere else

Tanikia Johnson: Great deals and good pizza.. My favorite is the parmasesn garlic bites

Gavin Hanks: Garbage service, wait time so far of 3 hours for a few pizzas, called twice and customer service is terrible as well, will never eat here again at least this specific weinbach location🙄 and I advise everyone to do the same, there’s so many better options

Mitchell Lester: They do a great job at this location! All my orders have been great, the customer service was great. All around great place to get some pizza.

Winona Williams: Always great service! Excellent delivery and delicious food!

Patty Hite: Cheep and tasty pizza

Chris Phelps: Awesome crew

Darren Smelser: Late night dinner and Domino's had it hot and ready in a short time for us.

Louis Wilson: Fast cheap and good

Andria Campbell: The wait was longer than stated. But the food was so good

LovelyLifeMom LovelyLifeMom: Best pizza had from any dominos before

Caiden Griggs: This Dominoes is the best pizza place in all of Evansville. The pizza is always fresh and hot, and they are very fast with delivery. I’ve never had any issues with this store, they do a great job and make great food. Thank you Dominos 1st Ave!

Anastasia Meriwether: Ordered from here and my pizza was not a circle and my brownie was half done never again will I ordered this s*** .

adubord20: Quality has went downhill the last few times I have ordered. Prices are ridiculous for the portion size as well. After being a customer of ten years I’m done and going elsewhere.

Judy Nunn: First time but not good pizza greasy on bottom middle on top needed more time, brownies extra greasy and burnt

The Mango: The pizza was really good. It had a lot of sauce on it which is personally my favorite part of pizza. I never actually went inside so I don't know what it's like in there or how the staff is.

Jennifer Shaw: Poor customer service. Argumentative crew members. Yelling over loud music because they can not hear the customer's speaking to them at the counter at 8pm. We will not be back second issue's in two weeks time. BURNT PIZZA also.

Marvin Johnson: Very disappointed with their service, customer and food! Ordered over $50 worth of food & got some of their 5 cheese dip, get it and it’s just all burnt cheese! Contacted them & talked to the manager & he said he would have someone bring another out (which is right down the road) to replace it and they never even show up! If someone spends money they want what is advertised!

G D. Fluker: Pizza was extremely dry!!!

Ted Jackson: Never had a bad experience. Until now. Needs new management.

Kenneth Thomas: I eat here 3x a month or more. Great staff, they need more help but they take care of their customers. Amazing service, food arrives fast and correct about 95% of the time but they always fix the problem and keep customers happy! 10/10 will always come back

gdvm1000: Nothing like burnt pizza. Terrible service. Seriously this is the best quality they have?

David Willis: Good people the gm especially very much appreciated

Kelly Scott: Pizza was yummy! Employees were very nice.

Ben Moore: DONE! Last time ordering from here. Every time I get delivery, and order a drink, they send the wrong one. DIET COKE, and Regular ARE NOT THE SAME THING! Most of the time I catch it, and send the driver straight back. This time, I stupidly didn't check til way later. Diabetic. Can't just drink regular. $3 wasted, cause drivers can't read.

jo si: Amazing!!!!!

Jerry Hart: Great deals when you sign up and order online. Good pizzas at great prices. Always ready on time and friendly staff. Hard to beat.

Wilda Bisesi Hahn: Pretty good pizza and the servers r good 👍!

Laura Guinn: Very slow service. Food was good

Bobby Sears: Fast courteous service, chicken wings were great too

Kelly Fouse: Fast. Easy ordering online and pay in store..

Amanda Hall: Very fast and friendly ☺️

Brandon Kelley (DatguyBK): I placed the order online and as soon as the tracker popped up it said in the oven. I thought that they probably just bumped the order off the screen which made it move up a step towards completion. I arrive to the store 10 mins later and decide to go in early and pay. I walked in and saw a pizza that looked like mine at the end of the oven. Then Sam came running around and sliding up to box it up like a pizza madman! I was surprised it was mine that fast. He handed it to me and sprinted to grab my drink. Sam is the person you want at all your locations. I hope the store knows this and he gets the requisition he deserves!

Summer Hatfield: The new crew needs to get their act together. Quality has dropped tremendously.

Tabitha Brown: Food took over an hour. Pizza was ice cold. I will stick with papa johns.

Michael Bennitt: I've ordered from this particular Domino's many times, for delivery to both my home and my workplace. My orders have always arrived when promised and they were hot, fresh, and correct. The Italian sandwich is my absolute favorite thing on their menu.

Ariel Smith: 2 hours is a ridiculous wait time , when being told 50 minutes.

Niterider Allen: Changing my rating, last couple pizzas we got from there are actually pretty darn good. As long as they don't keep it in the oven for too long, they're really good pizzas

S Hoskinson: Slow but pizza was great

Chris Hoskinson (Hoski): Little slow but pizza was assume

Brian Hite: Easy and fast. Pizza and sandwiches are good.

Pam Jennings: Our order was delayed more than 30 minutes from the time quoted but this didn't compare to the person who took my call. She was beyond rude and let me know she could care less then she hung up on me. WOW!!

Elizabeth McReynolds: Love their Alfredo!

Lacey L: I ordered a large bbq pizza with chicken bacon and cheddar cheese. I picked it up right before work. As soon as I entered the building a lady was standing there at the counter asking if I was Lacey. She then proceeded to tell me my pizza only looked burnt because she did not put the cheddar under the mozzarella. Now, I use to work for dominos for 3+ years. I KNOW that putting the cheddar on top or under the other cheese does not make a difference. That is only the case with feta, spinach, and phillysteak. I just took the pizza because I had no time to wait for it to be remade. When I got in the car you could smell that it was burnt. The crust was a dark brown. So when I got off I called and the man I spoke with told me to call back in 15 minutes and speak to their assistant manager. So I did just that and someone answered but put me on hold and I sat on hold for a good minute. I finally hung up because at that point I knew they just didnt want to deal with it. That is super unprofessional. I order from this location a good bit. Going forward I will use a different location. That is just ridiculous that a customer has to pay for a pizza that THEY burnt. I wouldnt be so worried if it was just the wrong topping..but being burnt?? No thank you.

Annie Dwyer: Great place to eat

Michael “Boxtown” Blankenship: 100% fabulous! Great staff. Westside Pizza delivery champions! Better boss award goes to Chris, best looking, best tasting pizza hand down!

Jennifer Powers: Everything was delivered hot and fresh!!

Shortina Rogers: I love this place order all the time but tonight it was terrable my pizza was burnt no sause on it i am very dissapointed

Jeff Nall: This specific store is really well run. Great people!

Ashley Clark: I ordered my food at 9:13 it’s 11:02 and still have not received my food. Can’t get anyone to answer the phone.. very bad experience

Brittney Morales: Best domino's ever. Food is always fresh, hot and delicious! Love this place!

Susan Smith: Fast, affordable and amazing quality. :) You got it goin on Domino's on Weinbach!

Dustie Barnes: I ordered two hours ago and barely got my food now. The delivery driver was super kind, but I told the driver that I called the store multiple times and he told me that they shut their wifi off and we're NOT answering calls at All! He told me they were tired of people calling into the store to order on the phone!!

K M: They are pathetic. I called the store because my online order had no buffalo sauce on them. The manager didn't care and still had to wait ANOTHER 40 minutes for my order. Side note. The delivery guy was very nice both times

devin pope: This location is always on point! Perfect

Jaymie Belka: You will wait 1-2 hours to get your food. Even if you live 4 minutes away. And it will be disgusting and old 😀

Melanie J Watkins: My husband had to go back to get our $1.25 garlic butter. This store is always inconsistent 🙄.

Bobby Ray: Good food no problems

Matt Griesemer: Couldn't even place an order. Online said it wasn't possible and I should call in. I called in and no answer for a solid 10 minutes. Completely unacceptable.

Scott Pfin: Great

Rose: Their pizza is good but they skimp on the toppings, I called them to ask if they could remake the pizzas because they was BARELY ANY olive or chicken on my pizza but the lady gave me attitude and HUNG UP ON ME!! For my second pizza there was BARELY ANY pineapple on it, plus it looked like someone had pick off most of the pineapple on the drive to my house!

Tyler: Second time ordering delivery from here. Second time that the order has taken hours to deliver. Last time I was told that the driver didn't have phone to contact me, so it got returned to the store this happened twice that day. Today, I'm still waiting on my food. Don't order from here if you want your food fast

Stephanie L: Our go-to for fast and easy yumminess!

Dawn Michelle Seidl Godsey: I love their customer service and pizza!

Brandi “Foxyeyez” Moore: It was ok

Lucretia Sherman: Make sure you say exactly what you want on your pizza how you want your pizza the size crust you would like for your pizza specifically say cut it in squares or just slice my pizza the brownies they had they should have kept the breadsticks are good the cheese needs to upgrade cheese cups Mariners good garlic sauce is good garlic butter drinks good and if the phone is too busy to answer at least say Domino's Pizza can you hold please

R VL: Not so fast but you always get what you order.

Valerie Ryan: Second time ordering and was thinking maybe the first time was just bad luck.Food is great.Delivery time is over an hour, both times. We live within walking distance. *face palm*This won't happen again.We will just order elsewhere.

Phillip Cunningham: Don't bother calling Domino's Pizza at North Green River Rd. I was on hold for 20 minutes just now and hung up. I'll find another pizza place who picks up the phone and wants to serve me/my money. You deserve less than 1 star...

Christopher Everett: Never order delivery in a hurry. Average is an hour or more for a single pizza. Be warned.

no name: Every time I order here they mess up my order. It took 35 minutes to make and quality check in total. And my house is 6 minutes away from the store and they took 20 minutes to deliver. And once they delivered my pizza to my neighbor when the numbers are next to the door! I am not ordering from here again.

Haley Rae: They withhold money from their employees. Not just one, multiple employees still haven’t received their payout from ONE night, over a MONTH ago. That is illegal !

Nick Swan: Did not answer phone

mike bellamy: Customer service was a 5! The fact that a 3 topping thin crust large pizza and 16 wings cost $38.?? was a 1. It sucked, both cost- wise and taste-wise. It’s not gourmet pizza, it’s fast food pizza. Never again will I go to Dominos.

REVENANT WR: Worst service in Evansville!Ordered the 4 for $5 soft drinks as part of my Mix and Match and only received 3 sodas.This is the 3rd time this location has forgot an item on my order. I forgave the first 2 but this time I immediately got on the phone to call and have them run my soda over since the delivery driver left in a hurry.I was on hold for a total of 1 hour on a Saturday evening!Twice they dropped my call after 15+ mins on hold and I even had a buddy with me call but to noone answering their phones as well.Decided to do their survey about my order and explained the situation. At the end of the survey they offered me 2 b.s. promos when all I wanted was to speak to an actual human and have them rectify the problem.I hit the 3rd option to not take advantage of their b.s. solution.I was expecting at least a follow-up email but 6 days later and I guess Domino's is now into the business of robbing their customers.I'll never order from Domino's again, any location!

Dan Whitehead: The staff at this store are very friendly, deliver fast, and always cook the food to perfection.

Michele Ruppert: The Dominos Store on N Green River Rd, Evansville, Indiana makes Thee Best Pizzas, & OTHER ITEMS, always Great, fast service, and delivery. THANKYOU SO MUCH !!!

Me, Myself And I: Man, mere words are incapable of describing how much I love this location! Not only is the food fantastic every time, but the staff really rocks!I get 4 cheese toppings on my deep dish pizzas, and they prepare it to perfection every single time!Side note: no other dominos location actually gives me what I've ordered/paid to get. Keep rocking on ya'll!-Steve

Ted Cruz: Cute manager, tossed my pizza real good and baked to perfection. 6/5.

Caymen Syder: As of my last order for delivery in March 2022, order was not only almost 45 minutes late (past max delivery estimate) but also cold. Terribly disappointed considering my stove & oven aren't in working to perhaps complete their job.

The Honestreview: I would have given 5 stars because of the fast delivery, but the store asks for a tip to pick up your own pizza. I didn't like that. It felt pushy and unnecessary. If you're going to pick up your own pizza, you might not have money for a tip, and it makes you look like you just want to tip when that's not the case....PLEASE LIKE THIS REVIEW vvvvvvvvvvBELOWvvvvvvvvvv

Me, Myself AndI: Phenomenal crew, and without any doubt they make my exceedingly cheesy deep dish better than any other location, and the best deep dish cheesy goodness from any pizza shop, bar none!This crew seriously deserves some extraordinary recognition!Always appreciated!***Plz please plz get this message forwarded to Dominos corporate offices, they may also contact me directly***

Myida Alexandra: Pizza & cheesy bread looked & tasted wonderful !! Excellent customer service I was overall very satisfied! Props to the awesome workers

Steven Eisenhauer: Don't get the specials. Get double topping and extra sauce now thats a great pizza.

Rhonda Faulkner: Great service. Store is clean and staff are great. Thanks

Ashley Savage: I've been calling this domino's for the last hr or so and no one is picking up the phone, I finally placed the order online but Im not sure if they are even open...I am very disappointed with the complete disregard for their customers and not at least answering and letting us know they only take online orders after a certain time..VERY DISAPPOINTED WITH DOMINOS

Cary Cowan: Our pizza was awesome!

Kara Eickhoff: Received my order 10 minutes ago, wings were great however my salad might be the worst looking salad I've ever seen. Still in shock that they thought it was in the slightest bit acceptable to deliver. I made sure to attach the picture. Do better domino's!