Business in Second Hand:
ADD MY BUSINESS
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Toy store
1. The Toy Drop - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 128 reviews
6025 Madison Avenue Suite: E, Indianapolis, IN 46227
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Charlie Baker: Great store and super friendly.
Joseph Lee-Cullin: Fun toy store, a lot of gems I did not expect to find.
jamie Def-Kiss: Friendly staff ,knowledgeable ,wide variety of new and collectibles, Every time we come in there it's always something new. We enjoy the shop very much.
Chris Badertscher: Such an awesome place! Was able to find some goodies to add to my collection!
Makenzie Taylor: Very cool place! It was a nice experience and the prices were great. There were many different kinds of toys and collectables like Star Wars, DC/Marvel, FunkoPops, Horror/Video Game Characters, Disney and many more. I'm definitely planning to go back.
THE EHMER FILES: Small but lots of stuff inside. Had a good time looking for some toys.
paulo lopez: Nice
Dustin Etting: Great customer service! Great seeing toys from my childhood. Fun store just to browse but also I have been able to find what I was looking for everytime ive gone.
Kenneth Williams: The Toy Drop is great! They have an excellent assortment of toys; have parking lot sales where they invite other sellers; and want to help you find that thing you are looking for. If you are looking for a vintage, hard to find, or random gift toy they are an excellent place to check out.
Jeffrey Podoshen: Lots of great stuff here. Owner is friendly and helpful.
Amyjo Mansfield: Found what I was looking for and the man that helped even dug threw the trailer to help me find the jack in the box
Melanie Surface: We LOVE this place! Family owned, very clean, and lots of unique toys and memorabilia. We visit monthly and always come out with treasures for ourselves and our baby daughter
Inman Jarrett: I always love going to the Toy Drop. The staff is super friendly. Toys are fairly priced. All around great store.
Beth Brooks-Moir: Hi! We had an excellent experience today! They have an awesome selection of Transformers, star wars, and pretty much anything you could hope for toy wise was there. We were treated very kindly, and we will be back in the future. Thank you!
Chris Garcia: Friendly Staff. Excellent variety of toy inventory.
kenneth golphin: Super friendly and lots to look at search through and great pricing!! Will definitely be back
King Boo: Went back to ask if I could renegotiate the prices - solid no. I'm not paying $20 for a Shaymin VSTAR card that's worth $1.82. This place is disgusting. Not even worth 1 star. You're better off at Comic Book University, trust me.Went in to sell some items and look at any Pokémon cards. Noticed they had a full arts Sidney card from Fusion Strike priced at $10. That is obscene. The market value for that card at the time of writing this review is $2.44. They also had a Celebrations Venusaur for $20! That card is marked at only $4.51! DO NOT BUY CARDS FROM HERE YOU WILL BE RIPPED OFF
Shawn Hicks: This is a woman using my boyfriend's account. We come here about twice a month or so recently. He took me there about 2 years ago. We love to view the displays and see the vintage items! The staff is very nice and funny! Definitely recommend
Aaron McKinney: Amazing store with amazing staff I’ve spent my fair share of money for my collection in this store
koreighsheighn: Awesome store. Awesome dudes. Awesome prices. Did I say awesome?
Brad Carroll: Lots of action figures. Pretty cool if you collect them.
Verified
Toy store
2. D's Vintage Toys and Collectibles - Marion County
Verified
· 144 reviews
2616 Brill Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Edward Gaddis: Decent selection but, prices the mark up is through the roof.
jamie c: I used to love trading and shopping here with D but since that red-headed guy has basically become co-owner he treats people like they don't know anything nothing they have is a value and he sure doesn't know anything about comic books been trading with D for years and buying and redhead told me I couldn't walk with a small box around the shop out of fear that I would steal something and that's not the only complaint many of us collectors have had similar run-ins with this guy's unprofessional behavior. If you're dealing with D it's a collectors find.
Dennis Johnston: Very good place got lots of needle toys a little overpriced but that's okay they got to pay the rent too not as high priced as attorneys have to pay when they bleed our pockets dry LOL God bless all yours very truly Mr Dennis Johnston
James Grizzel: This place is amazing. Great prices. They will make deals for you. Super friendly too!
THE EHMER FILES: Second time we have been here. It has a lot of toys from lots of lines new and old. Nice place.
Anna Domangue: Lots of old collectibles prices vary hi and low
Dennis Grass: Funkos were overpriced but had a wide selection
Cassandra VeHorn (Cassie): Very friendly & honest people alot of neat stuff in this store
Kelsay Bradley: Normally when my dad and I are here the owner is really nice and conducts himself professionally. However when the other guy is there without the owner (on Monday) and we’re told that we can’t sell there until Wednesday was news to us. Drove all the way down to Franklin where we sold our POPs and much more. Missed out on some good inventory.
Rachel Egarczynski: Amazing selection of toys and collectables
B K: Nice selection but charges e-bay prices, and not even the "sold" prices but the "listed" prices. So kind of a downer to find cool stuff that's priced above fair market value, sometimes way above. Still cool place to see but I'm into buying not just looking at museums.
Steven Lemaster: Great customer service, awesome selection of every kind of collectables you can ask for stop in there ASAP
Brendan Jones: Very nice and helpful staff! Great selection as well!
Harry Sering: Great selection of reasonably priced comic books
Brandon Ricks: This place was awesome. I hope to pass thru and stop in again one day. They have ALOT of everything here.
COLLIN HENRY: Awesome collections of toys! Overpriced though in my opinion. Still a really neat place and when checking out. Brings back some memories.
kenneth golphin: Super friendly lots to look at and fair pricing!
beth smith: Hubby's favorite toy store‼️ Always something old you need
Jason Carrington: Very ool
Geoff Gojko: Wonderful place to shop for old toys and add to your collection. Awesome robots, figures and diecast inventory. This place is so much fun to visit. So much to see. Friendly staff. Highly recommended. They accept trades for in store credit btw and their prices are Great!
BB King: If the books are not priced right then they shouldn't be out for sale. Lost a big sale and customer.
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Toy store
3. The Toy Pit - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 295 reviews
9402 Uptown Dr #700, Indianapolis, IN 46256
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Corey Hamilton: This place is crazy awesome! They, have such a huge collection ranging from pops, action figures to collectible statues! If your looking to build up on some awesome stuff get here now!!The staff was very welcoming and answered all my questions as well! Will be coming back soon!
Omar De Jesus Sabino: best toy store in Indiana! Huge selection and happy to work bundle deals and always make a point to take care of their customers! I will keep coming back!
Glenda Pineda: Love the TOYSSS LOVE IT
P B: Store had a decent selection. The store is smaller than it appears in the pictures on the website. There were toys scattered all over the floor, and no matter what they say they are overpriced. The staff stayed behind the counter talking to each other or on their phones. They put price tags on the boxes. Not a good first impression and most likely won’t be back.
irvin martinez (Memo_mtz): Second time going and they have lots of funkos to choose from and can even find chances as well. I found a couple that i couldnt even find online but they also have a variety of other toys/figures as well.
Jason Lowry: Helpful staff and had what I wanted at decent prices
Joshua Nixon: They had so many great selections and asked if we needed anything multiple times while looking around. They even had a good deal for the items I got, I recommend to collectors casual and hard-core!
Ashley Hanson: Love this place! So much to choose from!
Pix: Great store have been coming for months, staff is friendly and always willing to work with you. They have a wide selection for just about everything. I’d go here any day over Kokomo toys and other competitors.
Gavin Craig: I always find something cool in here, and the guys that run the store are helpful and very friendly
David West: The owner and staff at Toy Pit are AWESOME! Very friendly and very fair with their prices as well as fair offers when you are selling to them! I will definitely continue to do business with them! Huge selection! If you can’t find it here chances are they never made it! Make sure you check out their sidewalk sales this spring/summer! Happy Hunting!
koja: Wonderful store with an amazing selection! The staff was really nice and helpful and the prices are good. Definitely a place for anyone to go and take a look! Definitely the place to find some hidden gems!
David Frohbieter: Great selection. Staff is knowledgeable and friendly
Mr. Mansa: Great place to buy, trade and just hang out and chat about every part of the hobby!! Always willing to go the extra for the customer. I’ve been a customer for more than 4 years now and I can’t recommend The Toy Pit enough!!
David Arellano: Very good store. I recommend it to any figure collector. The workers are always helping the customers and have great deals.
Moises Sanchez: Tons of variety and always something new every time I’m here!! Definitely the best toy shop in Indy!
Michael Schott: Love this store! Proud of my nephew and his team!
Ken Jenkins: Staff was very friendly and very patient with me as I decided on which Hot Toys 1:6 figure to purchase. They had a good selection of pre-owned and new 1:6 scale Hot Toys.Also, they have a great selection of Transformers, Star Wars, GiJoe, and other toys we grew up with in the 70’s - 90’s.Worth a visit wether you are visiting Indianapolis or live in the metro area.
Traci Longanecker: The Funko collection is amazing! There were also several vintage toys in pristine condition. Love this place!
Mike Repischak: THE BEST TOY STORE EVER!!!! Great deals and friendly customer service!
Bruce Secor: To say The Toy Pit is amazing & fantastic seems a bit inadequate - I think we need some new adjectives! I've been buying there a few years now & it's a great place for a life-long Trekkie like me; they got even better with the move to their new, much larger space. I've been collecting Star Trek for 30+ years & it's become difficult to find items I don't have but Toy Pit always comes thru. I was there today & found a couple items at the parking lot sale & a couple more in-store. As always, Mike the owner & Stockton the manager were terrific, very knowledgeable & helpful. Today was one where they surprised me with a couple Trek items I didn't have & immediately bought. As someone who has collected for years, buying online & at other shops around the country, I find their prices reasonable & competitive; as the signs in the store say, if you want to negotiate a price, just ask them. I've always received excellent customer service there & I'm happy I live only a couple miles away. Live Long And Prosper! 🤓🖖
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Toy store
4. Happy Hen Toys - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 6 reviews
5335 N Tacoma Ave #22, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Jeffrey Soyster: Oh yeah. The best place to get thw animal figures you want. I don't go anywhere else
M BM: Ordered a couple of Breyer models and they shipped the same day! They arrived the next day as well, it probably helps that I am a state away but I was very impressed with the service and will definitely order my models more regularly from this store!
Stacy Jones: Great prices and I live in Indiana so I get items very next day my 5 year old son is very happy with toys he got especially the flying squirrel it was a lot bigger than expected
Diana H: Santa shops here!Hard to find presents are their speciality and the get to California with time to spare. Thank you for taking stress out of the holiday.
Alicia Laster: I thought I must've been scammed at first because when I received my email saying my items had shipped (December 1st) my tracking number never became live. But I received my package today (December 10th) of nice quality cowboy figurines and am very happy with everything. Also when I reached out to Happy Hen about not being able to track my package they did answer my email within a couple of days. Thank you Happy Hen Toys!!
Chance Givens: I ordered for the 2nd time from this place and both time I was very satisfied. I recieved my order faster then Amazon prime. I am a collector and was impressed by the care in the packaging. I will definitely order again.
Erica Carter: Ordered from them online for Christmas. They had the best price for the Brio train set we wanted to get. It was painless and shipping was fast. We also got a few other things there (animal figures mostly) and we are totally satisfied.
pebblekit: Yes
Related inquiries Second Hand:
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Thrift store
5. The Toggery Resale Boutique - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 116 reviews
1810 Broad Ripple Ave Suite 4, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Toy store
6. Monon Toys and Crafts - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 8 reviews
6510 Cornell Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Thrift store
7. Mission 27 Resale - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 388 reviews
132 Leota St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Thrift store
8. Treasures On Tenth Thift Shop - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
3427 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46201
Address
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Thrift store
9. Indy Thrift Queen - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
6346 Colonnade Ct, Indianapolis, IN 46237
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Thrift store
10. Thrifty Threads - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 103 reviews
1501 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260
Address
Website
WhatsApp
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
Thrift store
11. Wheeler Mission Store + Donation Center - Marion County
Verify
Not verifiedThis business has not been claimed. Owners who claim their businesses can update their profile details, add photos, respond to reviews, and more.
Request your free profile now
· 181 reviews
2730 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Address
Website
WhatsApp
